The Ship Model Forum

The Ship Modelers Source
It is currently Mon May 12, 2025 8:29 pm

All times are UTC - 6 hours [ DST ]




Post a reply
Username:
Subject:
Message body:
Enter your message here, it may contain no more than 60000 characters. 

Smilies
:smallsmile: :wave_1: :big_grin: :thumbs_up_1: :heh: :cool_1: :cool_2: :woo_hoo:
View more smilies
Font size:
Font colour
Options:
BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON
Disable BBCode
Disable smilies
Do not automatically parse URLs
Question
type everything in between the quote marks: "N0$pam" Note the Zero:
This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
   

Topic review - 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun Mts.
Author Message
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Fliger747 wrote:
Hank:
Cages are now in place on all four beam mounts. I don't think the centerline mounts had them though I could see where the aft mount might have used them.
Looks as if the bosun's just strung standard netting from their supply locker when needed.


I agree, the side (4) mounts did have cages; none on either the fwd. or aft mount.

Hank
Post Posted: Thu Mar 27, 2025 9:57 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Hank:

Cages are now in place on all four beam mounts. I don't think the centerline mounts had them though I could see where the aft mount might have used them.

Looks as if the bosun's just strung standard netting from their supply locker when needed.
Post Posted: Thu Mar 27, 2025 1:58 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Fliger747 wrote:
Hank:
Looking so far at the photos I am not sure that the Alaska had the casing cages during the early 1945 period for which I am modeling "her". Will research further.
Tom


Tom,
I just added a post to the CB-1 thread on the CASF forum. I wasn't aware of your late war (1945) configuration. But, if you look at pg. 50 in the Warship Pictorial #43, the cages ARE in place - that photo is dated 21 Feb 1945, so that might fit into your model's time frame. FYI - that photo is hard to pick up details but using a magnifying glass I did see the cage!!

Hank
Post Posted: Fri Mar 14, 2025 8:58 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Hank:

Looking so far at the photos I am not sure that the Alaska had the casing cages during the early 1945 period for which I am modeling "her". Will research further.

Tom
Post Posted: Fri Mar 14, 2025 12:54 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Fliger747 wrote:
Hank:
I haven't seen any scaled drawings of those mount baskets and need to double check to see if they were present in the period I am portraying the ship.
Tom


Tom,
My guess is that items such as those baskets would only be shown on construction drawings related to that particular ship (class). In this case I've seen photos of both CB-1 and CB-2 that had those installed during construction. CB-3 wasn't far enough along before she was cancelled.

I have found several photos in the Warship Pictorial #43 (Alaska Class Cruisers) which show those baskets. I guess that in this instance whatever you came up with would have to be something original. Unless of course, you decide to fly east to NARA II and spend a few days researching the original microfilm... :doh_1:

Those photos I located are on pages 7, 14, 15, 18, and 21. I'm not positive, but I also think from looking over the photos in the booklet that not all the 5" mounts had those cages. I am only seeing them on the side 5" mounts both fwd and aft of the aircraft catapult; nothing located on the centerline fwd or aft mounts. I think I also saw one photo which had the catch bag installed around the cage, but don't quote me on that!! One other (possible) detail that appears to me (am I seeing things??) is that a single vertical row of hand grabs on those mounts have been installed closer to centerline on the rounded back face of the mount in order to accommodate those cages. In addition, it also appears that the vertical row of hand rungs on either side of those four mounts were not installed at all. That feature would certainly be different than the typ. Mk. 28 gun mount. Upon closer inspection of the photos (1944), none of the five-inch gun mounts had the vertical row of hand rungs on either side. That might also be a modification you may consider while adding the cages, etc.


It doesn't look to me to be too difficult to design those cages, actually rather simple affairs. From the photo on page 7, it appears that the cage was centered around each of the 2 casing ejection hatches on the rounded after side of the mount.
You should create a new thread on the ALASKA forum and give it a go!!! :thumbs_up_1:

I hope this is of help...!

Hank
Post Posted: Thu Mar 13, 2025 8:42 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Hank:

I haven't seen any scaled drawings of those mount baskets and need to double check to see if they were present in the period I am portraying the ship.

Tom
Post Posted: Thu Mar 13, 2025 4:30 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Fliger747 wrote:
Alaska mounts had some fairly unique baskets on the aft bulkhead to catch ejected 5" casings, wonder if these are possible in 1:196. Many details in the various mounts that are now possible on a ship by ship basis. Same issue with paint mixing as I have her done in the neutral greys.


Tom,
Could very well be possible. With your new, higher res printer, you should certainly consider designing them and see what happens. Nothing to lose, right?

Hank
Post Posted: Sat Mar 08, 2025 8:00 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Alaska mounts had some fairly unique baskets on the aft bulkhead to catch ejected 5" casings, wonder if these are possible in 1:196. Many details in the various mounts that are now possible on a ship by ship basis. Same issue with paint mixing as I have her done in the neutral greys.
Post Posted: Sat Mar 08, 2025 7:31 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
This person was not appreciated before when he was under the guise of DavidP and is currently not appreciated by numerous people under his current nom de guerre .
Post Posted: Sat Mar 08, 2025 9:00 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
such unbecoming of a moderator to name call & swear at another member on this site. I have never done that on the 2 sites that I had & am moderating for.
I asked a simple question & you go into pissy mode. what your blood pressure tho I most likely have that beat.
Post Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2025 1:52 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Fliger747 wrote:
Hank:
The re done 5" mounts came out quite well. Following your example, I am yet (third version?) replacing my mounts on Missouri (1:192) as the very nice ones I have on there are the same as Alaska's and the wrong mod, having training buffers etc. They came out very nicely and the "hangup" is paint. For this ship I mixed my own colors and of course that paint batch is long deceased. Mixing paint runs in the PITA category of hobby experiences. I use a slightly different method of attaching them as there are magnets under the deck and I simply use a small recessed screw at the bottom. They seem to adhere strongly, are centered and rotate easily. When I do paint them, I'll need to do the greased recoil sleeves!
Tom


Tom,
Thanks for the nice comment! They ARE appreciated!! Isn't it great that when upgrades are needed, we can provide many of the (3D) parts ourselves?? As for painting, I agree - it's normally a PITA and one of the necessary "chores" in this hobby. As for the recoil sleeves, I was using two Testor spray colors, gold and gunmetal, sprayed one after the other while the first one was still wet; light coats, both. My gunmetal spray can is pretty much empty although I do still have one partial bottle of that color. The combination gave a somewhat "dirty" goldish result which was very close to the actual 5" gun barrel. These current barrels were done with the gold only but will have to suffice as is.

On this particular design of the mount, I used a 2mm dia. pin on the bottom and drilled out the according hole in the mount base on the model. I've spot glued each mount to keep it in place as once the display case is replaced, I don't want the mounts to fall off if something (such as a sneak Commie rocket attack) were to topple the model, etc. :doh_1:

Hank
Post Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2025 8:38 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
FFG-7 wrote:
are you certain it is 6" saluting guns not 6 pdr saluting guns?


We can always count on the Forum Troll (DavidP, FFG-7 or whoever else this asshole claims to be on any given day) to find something (typo in this case) to complain about on other modeler's threads. And by the way, proper English sentence structure would be starting sentences with a capital letter.

You're NOT WELCOME on my threads, PERIOD!!! Go bother someone else with your petty BS!
Post Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2025 8:21 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Hank:

The re done 5" mounts came out quite well. Following your example I am yet (third version?) replacing my mounts on Missouri (1:192) as the very nice ones I have on there are the same as Alaska's and the wrong mod, having training buffers etc. They came out very nicely and the "hangup" is paint. For this ship I mixed my own colors and of course that paint batch is long deceased. Mixing paint runs in the PITA category of hobby experiences. I use a slightly different method of attaching them as there are magnets under the deck and I simply use a small recessed screw at the bottom. They seem to adhere strongly, are centered and rotate easily. When I do paint them I'll need to do the greased recoil sleeves!

Tom
Post Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2025 6:45 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
are you certain it is 6" saluting guns not 6 pdr saluting guns?
Post Posted: Sat Mar 01, 2025 11:11 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
My Yard Availability period is now complete - a resounding success!! :thumbs_up_1: The following items were replaced during this short period:
(10) 5"/38 Dual Gun Mounts
(6) Mk. 56 Fire Control Directors
(4) 5" ZUNI CHAFF Rocket Launchers
(2) 6 pdr Saluting Cannon (added)
(2) UHF Antenna Platforms
All of these parts were 3D Design/Printed with a much higher level of detail than my own scratch built, original kit, or 3rd party purchased parts had which has given the model a much more detailed look. This was one of the main goals of this mini-project. Here are some photos of the completed overhaul -
Attachment:
Port Side Parts Replaced_1.jpeg
Port Side Parts Replaced_1.jpeg [ 535.34 KiB | Viewed 655 times ]

Attachment:
Port Side Parts Replaced_2.jpeg
Port Side Parts Replaced_2.jpeg [ 585.24 KiB | Viewed 655 times ]

Attachment:
RADAR Antennas Replaced_2.jpeg
RADAR Antennas Replaced_2.jpeg [ 430.84 KiB | Viewed 655 times ]

Attachment:
Stern Antenna Platform Replaced.jpeg
Stern Antenna Platform Replaced.jpeg [ 473.37 KiB | Viewed 655 times ]

Compare these photos with the earlier photos I posted prior to the replacement of these parts. Only thing left now is for requesting assistance from "The Admiral" for help in replacing the display case and then moving the model back to its proper location. I'm hoping that after self-DOGEing, the processing time for this request will be in days rather than weeks! :doh_1:

Hank
Post Posted: Sat Mar 01, 2025 10:04 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
The Admiral has ordered my shipyard closed for several days while it's employee (me!) self-DOGEs in compliance with the Fed. mandates for down-sizing and efficiency. When "The Admiral" speaks, (i.e. her Cat speaks!!), I listen!!! One doesn't want to run afoul of "The Cat". Besides, with temps up in the low 70s here, it's obviously time to get things in the Tomato Patch cleaned up and ready for Spring planting. And also ( :mad_1: ) time to clean out "The Admiral's" flower garden beds!!

Currently, I'm getting close to wrapping up this Yard Period with the replacement of the stern UHF antenna platforms (P/S). And lastly, spot gluing the new 5" gun mounts in place will finish this very successful maintenance period. I should have some final photos to post after the work is complete.

As the DOGE reports are due on "The Admiral's" desk shortly, I'd better get my butt in gear :doh_1:

Hank
Post Posted: Thu Feb 27, 2025 9:20 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Well, things have progressed on this overhaul and I've been able to find more information on one of the weapon systems we had on board - the Mk. 28 ZUNI Chaff Launchers. My original scratch built versions were rather crude -
Attachment:
Scratch built ZUNI Launcher.jpeg
Scratch built ZUNI Launcher.jpeg [ 417.9 KiB | Viewed 393 times ]

As such, I have wanted to replace these with something more detailed and correct. I finally found information regarding these launchers and have now 3D design/printed those parts and they are installed -
Attachment:
3D Des-Printed ZUNI_1.jpeg
3D Des-Printed ZUNI_1.jpeg [ 61.13 KiB | Viewed 393 times ]

Attachment:
3d Des-Printed ZUNI_2.jpeg
3d Des-Printed ZUNI_2.jpeg [ 43.3 KiB | Viewed 393 times ]

The devil is in the details! These now look correct and I'm happy with the results!

Another couple items that I've 3D designed and printed are the two stern whip antenna platforms and the starboard refueling boom. I may have to do some further design on the antenna platforms as these are quite tiny and will need patience to assemble with the antenna wire and then install. Adjustments are part of the game. All (10) 5" gun mounts are now complete and in place (no glue). I'm debating whether or not to use a drop on each mount bottom or leave as is; leaning towards a tiny drop just to make sure they don't come loose. The AN-SPS-6C RADAR antenna is in place and I hope to install the AN-SPS-6C tomorrow. I managed to mess up the platform railing while removing the original antenna so I 3D des/printed the railing and will make a final adjustment to that design tonight and reprint in the morning. The original railings are all PE from PONTOS but the 3D versions simply look better although are a beach to handle as they're much more delicate than the PE brass parts are.

Hank
Post Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2025 9:30 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
Here is the completed saluting gun such as the photo of the USS SALEM shows -
Attachment:
1-48 scale Saluting Gun_2.JPG
1-48 scale Saluting Gun_2.JPG [ 8.78 KiB | Viewed 441 times ]

I'll probably print these tomorrow.
Post Posted: Sun Feb 16, 2025 10:35 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
I dug out the 1967 BoGP for BB-62 and the saluting guns are not specified as to the size of the gun, etc., only that 2 of them would be shipped -
Attachment:
BB-62 1967 BoGP Plan.jpeg
BB-62 1967 BoGP Plan.jpeg [ 495.65 KiB | Viewed 454 times ]

In addition, here is the plan view of that area of the deck showing the 2 saluting guns -
Attachment:
BB-62 1967 Saluting Battery Plan_1.jpeg
BB-62 1967 Saluting Battery Plan_1.jpeg [ 175.69 KiB | Viewed 454 times ]


Here is the 1956 BoGP for BB-64 in which the saluting guns are actually called out -
Attachment:
BB-64 1956 BoGP Plan.jpeg
BB-64 1956 BoGP Plan.jpeg [ 485.46 KiB | Viewed 454 times ]


I did find a few photos of the saluting guns on USS SALEM (CA-139) as a museum ship and these are closer to what I recall as being on board NEW JERSEY during her 3rd commission -
Attachment:
Saluting Gun_1.JPG
Saluting Gun_1.JPG [ 78.8 KiB | Viewed 454 times ]


So, without being able to locate a copy of BuOrd Pamphlet 1112, First Revision, which would more than likely have the 6 pd cannon listed, I'll 3D design/print the version on board USS SALEM and we'll call it a day; this I think, approximates the version as close as I can determine at the current time.

Hank
Post Posted: Sun Feb 16, 2025 5:00 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/200 scale Replacement Parts for Mk. 56 FC & 5"/38 Gun  Reply with quote
DrPR wrote:
Hank,
The NJ had 3 pounder saluting guns? I thought by WWII they were using 40 mm saluting guns. 40 mm blank shells. That is what the cruisers had.
Phil


Phil,
Well, now that you've brought it up, I'll have to check on that - I just "assumed" that the 3 pdr. was installed. Boy, shouldn't I have learned about "assuming" things in Boot Camp??? :bash_2:

Luckily, I have those items painted but not mounted in place. You wouldn't have any plans available for the 40mm model, would you? This is one of those pieces of ordnance that usually gets overlooked on most models. I don't have any real close up pix of those saluting platforms.

Hank

9:15 am Edit - The 1950 BoGP for MISSOURI and the 1956 BoGP for WISCONSIN show (2) 6lb. saluting guns on each side. The 1955 BoGP for NEW JERSEY calls out (2) saluting guns but doesn't give the size. My 1967 BoGP for NEW JERSEY is rolled up and I'll need to consult it. I'm pretty sure that those saluting guns were not changed during her 1967 refit but will dig out the drawing just to make sure!
Post Posted: Sun Feb 16, 2025 8:46 am

All times are UTC - 6 hours [ DST ]


Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group