The Ship Model Forum

The Ship Modelers Source
It is currently Thu Mar 28, 2024 12:00 pm

All times are UTC - 6 hours [ DST ]




Post a reply
Username:
Subject:
Message body:
Enter your message here, it may contain no more than 60000 characters. 

Smilies
:smallsmile: :wave_1: :big_grin: :thumbs_up_1: :heh: :cool_1: :cool_2: :woo_hoo:
View more smilies
Font size:
Font colour
Options:
BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON
Disable BBCode
Disable smilies
Do not automatically parse URLs
Question
type everything in between the quote marks: "N0$pam" Note the Zero:
This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
   

Topic review - 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711
Author Message
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Interestingly, I'm in that photo as well...far left side, squinting real hard, with an ugly mustache.

KV_Pharoh knows who I am...

Glad that your daughter enjoyed the paper ships!

If you need any detail on CHA, feel free to drop a line....
Post Posted: Fri Dec 07, 2012 9:04 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
KV_Pharaoh! Now that's one username I haven't seen in a long long time. Glad to see you back, and thank you for the unique account of Charlottetown off Libya!
Post Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2012 12:33 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
whytewolf wrote:
Previously on "Scratch-building by a Dummy...." :)

The cox'n of SUMMERSIDE--Chief John Birks--invited us to stay aboard for lunch, and I have to say, compared to the rations we army boys received when I was serving...well, the navy makes one mean steak.

I presented her CO with a framed copy of this beauty shot shown below--which I am told will be hanging in the wardroom! I also got a larger copy signed by the CO and Chief Birks to hang on my wall here in Calgary.

It turns out that Chief Birks wife serves aboard HMCS CHARLOTTETOWN--the only other serving Canadian warship named for a PEI community--which at the time was serving off the coast of Libya in Operation MOBILE. CHARLOTTETOWN in fact has been the first Canadian warship to take and return hostile fire since the Korean war--so it's the Op MOBILE version I've decided I'll build of this now historic vessel--but I don't expect to be starting that project for a while yet. In 1/72 she'd be 6 feet long!



Sean,

Just wanted to weigh in to congratulate you on an outstanding build and offer my thanks as a serving member of the RCN for this outstanding tribute to the men and women who have served and will serve in SUMMERSIDE. I understand you won't be tackling CHARLOTTETOWN in the immediate future but I would like to offer my services in your aid when that time comes. I served as her Above Water Warfare Officer during our time off Libya last year and can provide a "modeller's perspective" of her fit at the time you intend portraying her.

A little known fact about CHA (one that hasn't been overtly published by a major media outlet at least) is that we received "credit" for three specific engagements that occurred during the Libya Campaign. Besides our direct role in enforcing the no fly-zone and countering the small boats attempting to mine the harbour approaches to Misratah we served as a targeting unit via direct observation and intelligence gathering. In that role we achieved what I consider to be our most important results; 270 of 600 enemy positions reported by CHA were struct by NATO airstrikes (artillery, main battle tanks, truck mounted rocket launchers, technical vehicles, ammo dumps and command centre targets were all that was recorded). In recognition of this, CHA was awarded credit for three specific instances were it was assessed that without CHA's participation in the targeting chain the engagement simply would not have happened (for clarification these three engagements were not against individual units, but large groups directly engaging the civilians trapped in the port). This unique honour was displayed as three "Mission Marks" in the shape of a GBU-12 that I had our hull technicians construct out of aluminum and bolt to each bridge wing during our port visit to the Grand Harbour in Malta. These were displayed for one year and are presently in the possession of the Maritime Command Museum in CFB Stadacona, I had painted the dates of the three events on the back of each shape, but I can't recall any besides April 26 2011 right now. Another unique feature you might try and incorporate into an OP Mobile CHA was her entitlement to wear two Canadian Forces Unit Commendations simultaneously. These are displayed as flags flown from the outer starboard yardarm and are flown for one year following the award. CHA's were awarded during our final port visit, in Palma de Mallorca. One award was for CHA's participation in the Persian Gulf in 2007/2008 and the second for her time in Libya 2011, it is the only time a unit has been awarded two simultaneously.

Anyway, when you do get around to her please feel free to look me up, I'll happily make myself available for any research you might need including photo requests of the ship itself, I'm posted to the base in Halifax so it is no problem for me.

I'll attempt to attach a photo of her in Souda Bay which shows the placement of the mission marks.


Attachments:
CHA Crew 2011.jpg
CHA Crew 2011.jpg [ 165.04 KiB | Viewed 737 times ]
Post Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2012 12:09 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Thanks Russ! I am really proud of her--to be honest, it's felt almost like graduating to a new level of modeler. I'm a lot more confident about my skills and abilities, while at the same time, I'm having more fun with the hobby as I'm less inclined to be frustrated with things not working out as I envisioned it.

In a lot of ways, it's the same feeling I had when I finished my basic training, and became a "real" soldier :)

I'm watching your "Cadillac" build with interest. :thumbs_up_1:

I'm considering doing the second Annapolis at some point, although an early HMCS St Laurent in 1/96 has it's own charms--I love the look of that twin 3" on the bow! :heh:

Cheers,

Sean
Post Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 11:10 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
hi sean,your summerside is a real beauty,you can be very proud of her she is a very superb model.
Post Posted: Thu Mar 15, 2012 6:16 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Beautiful photo! Thank you sir, you are a gentleman and a scholar :)

Cheers,

Sean
Post Posted: Wed Mar 14, 2012 8:55 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
And here she is, taken from the bridge of Preserver:


Attachments:
2012-03-10-201.jpg
2012-03-10-201.jpg [ 2.11 MiB | Viewed 3104 times ]
Post Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 11:53 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Thanks Timmy! It was funny, when I was there in the summer, one of SUMMERSIDE's sailors was telling me how lucky I was to see her, as a couple of years before she had been in reserve, and he figured she's be laid up within the next couple of years. I picked the perfect window of opportunity I guess :)

Cheers,

Sean
Post Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 9:51 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
I was in Halifax just this past week/end! Saw Summerside by the pier and thought of this, haha! She looks great and you are right to be damn proud, Sean!
Post Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 7:19 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Sean, A very nice write up, very interesting, :woo_hoo: :woo_hoo: :woo_hoo: :woo_hoo: :wave_1:
Post Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 6:16 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Great build and you and your daughter seemed to have so much fun at the end.

I look forward to watching the Annapolis build. I am planning a future build in 1/72 of HMCS Niagara I-57.
Post Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 6:06 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Sean
You must be very proud of your Summerside .It looks perfect .Only it's creater can see it's flaws.Look forward to your next build . :thumbs_up_1: :thumbs_up_1: :thumbs_up_1:
Post Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 6:01 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Previously on "Scratch-building by a Dummy...." :)

I had preshaded the 1/72 scale hull...

So now we get down to June 3, the (Friday) night before the show. After a full day at the office (having successfully delivered a project and thus feeling pretty enthusiastic) I immediately came home for a marathon 12-hour session of painting, masking, re-painting, cursing over-spray, masking, painting, threatening to throw the model out a second-floor window, re-masking, re-painting, and finally, decaling. After a 2-hour nap, I promptly packed the whole kit and caboodle into it's Rubbermaid container for the 1-hour drive south to Nanton.

Image

And here we are in Nanton, where Sean realizes that he'd not thought to remove the masks from the bridge windows, and is frantically peeling off tape in the vain hope that one can be both gentle, and fast. :)

Image

Nonetheless, masking removed, and final loose fittings secured to the hull, SUMMERSIDE looked the part of a 1/72 warship--and perhaps while not the best model in her category (the top two were flawless) she certainly was the largest! Regardless, SUMMERSIDE did bring home Bronze in her category, and was awarded Best Canadian Naval Vessel (sponsored by the Resin Shipyard) and IPMS Canada Member's choice--both awards being very pleasant surprises to her now nearly comatose builder.....

After Nanton, it was back home for SUMMERSIDE to be packed in preparation for her cross-Canada journey. Safely stowed in her Rubbermaid container, and wrapped in multiple layers of twine, tape and this-side-up warnings, she--thanks to the graciousness of the Greyhound Gods--made it safe and sound to PEI. My daughter and I were to follow six weeks later.

Once on PEI I took the final assembly steps, including rigging the mast and flying the ship's call sign--and gluing down all the fiddly bits in a much more permanent manner. Here are a couple of "beauty shots" taken the night before her presentation.

Image

Image

Image

I was very pleasantly surprised at how enthusiastic the CO of HMCS QUEEN CHARLOTTE (the naval reserve unit in Charlottetown PEI) was to receive the model. Cdr. Gallant had an entire unveiling arranged, including, as a representative of the ship herself (at the time off the coast of Boston) the dear lady who had christened her 12 years before. I've included below some photos of the ship in her case--awards arranged with her, as well as some photos of myself and my daughter at the ceremony.

Image

Image

The final assembly awaits!

Image

In this one Rhane is pointing to the fingerprints she and I had left on an interior bulkhead 18 months before.

Image

And here are those self-same fingerprints.

Image

SUMMERSIDE in her new permanent residence.
Image

They asked me to say a few words.
Image

I even got a nice write up on the local newspaper!

Image

As an epilogue, when we were on our way back to Calgary--and as we were flying out of Halifax anyway--we had the distinct pleasure of touring the real HMCS SUMMERSIDE, just returned to HMC Dockyard in Halifax from Boston. It was a very strange feeling walking the decks of a ship I knew so intimately, but that I'd never set foot on before. Better yet, there were no glaring omissions on the model when compared to the real ship--save for the damage control panel on the port side of the bridge--I know of no photos or descriptions (I suspect for security reasons) and so had no detail on that part of the model's bridge.

Here you can see a couple of shots of my daughter aboard the real SUMMERSIDE

Sitting in the captain's chair....

Image

Sitting in the Bofors mount...

Image

Being generally pretty cute at the bow....

Image

The cox'n of SUMMERSIDE--Chief John Birks--invited us to stay aboard for lunch, and I have to say, compared to the rations we army boys received when I was serving...well, the navy makes one mean steak.

I presented her CO with a framed copy of this beauty shot shown below--which I am told will be hanging in the wardroom! I also got a larger copy signed by the CO and Chief Birks to hang on my wall here in Calgary.

It turns out that Chief Birks wife serves aboard HMCS CHARLOTTETOWN--the only other serving Canadian warship named for a PEI community--which at the time was serving off the coast of Libya in Operation MOBILE. CHARLOTTETOWN in fact has been the first Canadian warship to take and return hostile fire since the Korean war--so it's the Op MOBILE version I've decided I'll build of this now historic vessel--but I don't expect to be starting that project for a while yet. In 1/72 she'd be 6 feet long!

All in all, I really can't say how much I appreciate the dedication, effort and sacrifice of the men and women of the Canadian Navy. It was an honor to be aboard SUMMERSIDE and shake hands with her CO and cox'n.

Here are Rhane and I with Chief Birks on the bridge of SUMMERSIDE. Rhane's sitting at the helm--she get's all the good seats :)

Image

And so that wraps up my story. SUMMERSIDE was my first ship model, and my first really big scratch-building attempt. She turned out better than I could have hoped--even though at times during the build I was really close to consigning her to the dumpster. Maybe that's why I'm happier that she's on display 3000 miles away--I don't need to be looking at her flaws all the time. Beyond a lot of fun, and a huge sense of accomplishment in building her, this project has given me the opportunity to meet and interact with some amazing people--many of whom were essential in assisting me see this project through to completion. So, many thanks to Dennis Kaye for his words of experience, Scott McTavish for his photography, Darren Scannel for his research materials, Tim Cotey for his insight into the world of the MCDV, my Dad for being boots on the ground in PEI, Cdr Gallant for his belief and enthusiasm, my daughter Rhane for her patience--and not a few 'out of the mouths of babes' moments, and last but not least, Chief Birks and the crew of SUMMERSIDE--heck, the entire Canadian Navy for that matter--for being an inspiration for this old army guy.

But I have to say, I think I have the ship-building bug now but good. I'm already planning the next projects I'm going to undertake--including a turtle-back destroyer, HMCS ANNAPOLIS, a PEI car ferry.....all in 1/72 scale.

In any case, thanks for listening to my ramblings.

Cheers,

Sean

PS - So its been several MONTHS since I actually wrote the bit above, and despite my best intentions, I'm apparently pretty crappy at staying on top of actually having my writing published....

Since then I've started working on my next project--HMCS ANNAPOLIS (I-04)--and plan on adding a build log for her too. Meantime I've also been doing some work with a neat CAD app called Delftship. I'm by no means an expert; Lord knows the last time I worked with a CAD program, AutoCAD has release numbers and not dates...but I'm also including a screen shot at my initial attempts at doing a MCDV like SUMMERSIDE:

Image

What I like best about using Delftship is that I can sketch up a hull fairly rapidly, and then print out my drawings with any number of station or buttock lines etc. that I need for the project. I'm also exploring using the STL that Delftship can export to try some rapid prototyping of parts. Time and finances permitting of course.

So, once again, thanks to those of you who've taken the time to read this. I look forward to documenting ANNAPOLIS here as well--just hopefully faster than I did before :)

Cheers (again),

Sean
Post Posted: Tue Mar 13, 2012 5:07 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Will do! See you there - I'll be the Asian kid bringing the 1/700 Japanese cargo-liner.
Post Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2011 4:08 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Timmy,

I am, although it's looking more and more doubtful if my zebra-striped PT boat will be joining me.... :dead:

If you're there too and you see me wandering about (I'm the guy with the bushy beard and the HMCS SUMMERSIDE baseball cap) give me a shout :wave_1:

Cheers,

Sean
Post Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2011 10:28 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Lovely work, Sean! Will you be at the Alberta Military Modellers Show this weekend?
Post Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2011 9:32 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Thanks guys! I'm especially enjoying your hangar build Dave; I'm planning on using some Fleetscale fittings for a future build (of HMCS CHARLOTTETOWN in fact!) so I'm keen to see what a master modeler does with them :)

Cheers,

Sean
Post Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2011 5:39 pm
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Sean
superb :wave_1:
Post Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2011 8:11 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711  Reply with quote
Hi Sean you have been very busy producing a lot of nice work .I like your Zodiac conversion , good thinking.
Dave Wooley :thumbs_up_1: :thumbs_up_1: :thumbs_up_1:
Post Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2011 3:04 am
  Post subject:  Re: 1/72 HMCS Summerside MM 711 -- the rest of the story  Reply with quote
Well, needless to say things have been busy since I last posted here. For those who are spoiler junkies, let me just say the end of this adventure has made all of the effort worthwhile. For those wanting the rest of the story, read on...

When last I posted, I was working on the zodiacs for SUMMERSIDE. Based on my references, she would be carrying two--one large and one small.

Image

Thanks to a head-sup by a local model club member, I was able to pick up a 1/72 scale zodiac fairly cheap--it cost only the high-bid on Ebay for the vintage Jaques Cousteau PBY-5 kit (which includes a zodiac and two divers). I built it up and made several resin copies, one of which was cut in half, lengenthened and provided a deeper keel to make the larger RHIB.

Image

While picking away at on these two boats, work continued on other small(ish) details like parts of the anchor assembly, the rails for the life raft canisters, radar, flag lockers, air contitioners etc.

Image

Image

Image

The rails for the life raft canisters (my first attempt at soldering):

Image

Earlier I had sprayed the main deck(s) with a textured paint product--the sort of thing used to provide a faux-rock effect to outdoor furniture or whatnot. It replicated the ship's anti-slip texture quite well in this scale, but was very "hot" in that it had a tendency to melt styrene unless sprayed very lightly. Now I had to spray the decks on the super-structure, and after all the work put into it (including the bridge interior of which I'm very proud) I suddenly had visions of it all melting into a pile of chemical goo.

Image

Screwing up my courage, and masking more thoroughly than I have ever done before, I lightly sprayed the deck surfaces and crossed my fingers.

Image

After a few anxious minutes, I gently peeled back the masking to reveal miraculously undamaged bulkheads....and a pretty nice texture effect on the deck :)

Image

The last really major fitting needing completion prior to painting was the Bofors Boffin mount. I rebuilt the ready-use ammo rack since I wasn't pleased with how the short-cut I'd used (a cut-down inclined ladder) had turned out. I added some wire and etch to complete the siren assembly and kitbashed a "scooter" and associated hydraulics from the landing gear of a F-18 kit. I also stole a front seat from the old Esci US Guntruck kit for the operator's seat. Finally, I had a gun mount I was happy with.

Image

Image

Time was now getting short--I'd set a goal for myself in that I would have the model ready for display (and competition) at the Western Canadian Regional model show in Nanton Alberta for June 4. My typical two-steps-forward-one-back approach to modelling had left me with only a few days before the show to get everything done--not to mention the additional complication of needing to ship the model across the country after the show necessitating the disassembly of the most fragile fittings so they could be re-assembled once I made it to PEI in July. Suddenly the final fitting out became a rolling process where bits and pieces were strategicly glued in place (or tacked in place with Elmer's white glue and a prayer) in almost random order to make sure I wasn't disturbing not-yet-dry fittings while adding other fittings.

Image

At this time I ran several copies of the custom decals I would need on the printer at work--I'm glad I printed multiples as the ship's call-sign decals (they go above the forward bridge hatches) were really fragile, and out of six copies only one full pair could be made that wasn't damaged in some way. That said, the ship's crest turned out wonderfully, and I still have five left! Using a babrber-pole stripe from Hawk Graphic's 1/72 Halifax Class small marking decal set along with the crest, I painted and completed the ship's mast, and painted the main superstructure at the same time--to save some time it was hoped.

Image

With most of the really fiddly bits done, and with the stacks glued in place, I pre-shaded the hull, and began to add the railing staunchions to the main decks (the complete railings on the superstructure had aready been done shortly after I finished painting it). The stanchions were Billing's Boats 3-bar (flat style as opposed to ball); I'd hoped to design some PE ones, but my broken ankle last winter set me far enough back on the project I dropped the idea and went with the Billing's staunchions since they were "Close enough for Jazz".

Image

Image

To be continued.....

Cheers,

Sean

ps -- Hey NavyShooter, thanks for the tip! I'd seen these a while back when first considering the project, but had forgotten about them. I've downloaded them so my daughter can give it a go though :)
Post Posted: Wed Sep 14, 2011 5:46 pm

All times are UTC - 6 hours [ DST ]


Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group