The Ship Model Forum

The Ship Modelers Source
It is currently Thu Mar 28, 2024 11:27 am

All times are UTC - 6 hours [ DST ]




Post a reply
Username:
Subject:
Message body:
Enter your message here, it may contain no more than 60000 characters. 

Font size:
Font colour
Options:
BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are OFF
Disable BBCode
Do not automatically parse URLs
Question
type everything in between the quote marks: "N0$pam" Note the Zero:
This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
   

Topic review - Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set
Author Message
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
To all who has this 1/200 Mikasa detail set.
Some received sets might be missed correction fret.
If your set has following correction fret , please send me an email with Postal address and receiver name.
Image
And I am arranging some manual pages where Tobori noted.
You can download with PDF form from each modified page.

Thank you
Keumho Kim
Post Posted: Thu Jun 14, 2018 9:37 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
kruker wrote:
SovereignHobbies wrote:
When parts are missing or damaged, Pontos replace. Where parts simply don't fit, Pontos make correction parts.


I've PM them and emailed them at least 10 times already about replacement parts. I never got any reply from them. The customer service in Pontos is very poor imho.


I too have tried contacting them several times and get absolutely no response. Language barriers are one thing, but by totally ignoring a message, rather than acknowledging it, at least for clarification is another.
Post Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 10:12 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Since I might be looked at as one of those "picking" on Pontos, I am the first person to compliment Pontos on the incredible sets that they sell. I have said it several times. When I "pick" on Pontos, it's because Mr. Park listens to us and improves the kits and even modifies them according to some of the feedback that is voiced in these forums. So when I "pick" on Pontos, it's to notify them of the errors that I found and hope that they can fix them and IMPROVE their product to increase their sales and amazing quality. When you consider the amount of parts involved, the errors that I found were very minimal, and I appreciate that. I don't see my reporting errors as "picking" on Pontos, rather than "sharing" my experience and findings during the assembly of these kits. Isn't this what these forum are ultimately for?
Post Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 10:10 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
First allow me to indicate that I have found the attention to detail and precision engineering incorporated in the Pontos Detail Up sets is exceptional and unmatched by any other company’s products I have had the occasion to work with. Their instruction format does require careful study on occasion which in most cases can be resolved by enlarging the online copy to 400% (or greater). The builder's integration of the Pontos instructions with the kit instructions is probably a greater challenge.
To date, I have acquired both the 1/200 Bismarck and Hood sets and have completed the lion's share of the work in both kits (below). In the case of the Hood Detail Up set, it contains 20 photo etch sheets incorporating thousands of parts and 307 scribed brass components, so the chance of a part or parts being rendered unusable or lost by the builder is probably quite high. Pontos does provide extra parts in their sets in some cases but covering all eventualities in such a manner is impractical. So, I would hope that Pontos product support would/should offer replacement parts at fair market value plus postage. In that regard, I currently have placed and paid for an order for replacement parts with Pontos to address three parts I messed up (the pompom gun sights) and two brass parts I have lost. This order dates back a number of months now but fully understand that due to staffing and production considerations, orders such as mine take time. Now that a standard order form has been developed, I have since resubmitted my request. Hopefully the required parts will be provided in due course.ImageImage
Post Posted: Thu May 03, 2018 9:27 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
kruker wrote:
SovereignHobbies wrote:
When parts are missing or damaged, Pontos replace. Where parts simply don't fit, Pontos make correction parts.


I've PM them and emailed them at least 10 times already about replacement parts. I never got any reply from them. The customer service in Pontos is very poor imho.


When I last spoke with Kim, he acknowledged that he struggles with this but I personally think a part of it is because of the vastly different sentence structures etc between Latin based languages like English and Korean. Despite the brand's popularity it's still a very small business and like all small businesses, Kim is trying to juggle many things at once.

In the UK I am responsible for making good defects etc when I sell to UK customers due to our laws. The inability to get spares quickly was something I had to speak to Kim about and to be fair to him, he was pretty straight with me and didn't try any BS excuses. We agreed that for our customers the best way to get spares is to go direct but to limit text to the very basics. Of course, you may have already tried this one of the 10 times but if you did try to write nice emails, then I suggest one more try direct to Pontos using something like this - PM me with your email address if you want the native Excel file to fill in. :thumbs_up_1:

Attachment:
PontosSpares.jpg
PontosSpares.jpg [ 220.61 KiB | Viewed 1244 times ]


Kim and I agreed that sending one of these with subject heading as above is the best way to get spares, so I created the template to include in boxes we already have - he planned to include them in future shipments to try to improve the spares/replacements situation. He can just pass this on to packing staff to deal with and minimal translation etc is required. I try to help another Korean company with English regularly and have to admit the two languages do not mesh well at all. Using Google Translate or similar gives some utterly bizarre results!
Post Posted: Tue May 01, 2018 8:27 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
SovereignHobbies wrote:
When parts are missing or damaged, Pontos replace. Where parts simply don't fit, Pontos make correction parts.


I've PM them and emailed them at least 10 times already about replacement parts. I never got any reply from them. The customer service in Pontos is very poor imho.
Post Posted: Tue May 01, 2018 6:25 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
bielingg wrote:
I find it sad the way some members of this board are picking on PONTOS.
Since PONTOS arrived on the scene it has been a constant drip drip of negative outbursts with very little merit. I do not remember this kind of bile when there was only one or two companies on the market, producing product , product light years inferior to what Korea is producing for us today.
It must be very difficult for PONTOS to stay cool and reply in a very polite way to some of the accusation flying . I know their livelihood depends on it, that's why it is up to us to stop this barrage .

All you have to do is to read the pages and pages of their Bismarck set to get the idea here . This hurts the hobby and us all , I am really to old to still tinker with PE but I remember life before .
.


I'll be accused of bias no doubt, but I think people need a reality check.

The product is priced at a level a little above the competition, and the product is quite a bit more comprehensive. Nobody forces anyone to buy it. It's a lot of work. The amount of brass colour in the photographs gives a good hint at that.

To expect not to have to use any skills is a bit naive in my honest opinion. If a modeller thinks the quality is not up to standard then don't buy another and see how you prefer the competition or see how you get on scratchbuilding.

When parts are missing or damaged, Pontos replace. Where parts simply don't fit, Pontos make correction parts.

On this forum I've seen a lot of people giving Kim a hard time for not spending all his time answering a lot of useless questions (which first he has to translate - and Korean is not a particularly compatible language with English as far as syntax and sentence structure goes) and usually just to ask "when will you release <whatever I fancy building next>?"
I've seen someone upset because they'd have to transpose positioning information given on the instructions to the model manually. I've seen someone insisting that an assembly was IMPOSSIBLE to build despite it being assembled right there on the photographic instructions.

He's running a business and like many small companies there isn't a staff sitting waiting to answer stupid questions and surf foreign language forums looking for mentions to react to. And to say what? "Yes, that was a typo. Well spotted"?

Anyone who remembers the early GMM or WEM days with black sketches suggesting a part was attached 'roughly there' doesn't complain too much about Pontos instructions.

So, again, reality check.
Post Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2018 11:40 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
I find it sad the way some members of this board are picking on PONTOS.
Since PONTOS arrived on the scene it has been a constant drip drip of negative outbursts with very little merit. I do not remember this kind of bile when there was only one or two companies on the market, producing product , product light years inferior to what Korea is producing for us today.
It must be very difficult for PONTOS to stay cool and reply in a very polite way to some of the accusation flying . I know their livelihood depends on it, that's why it is up to us to stop this barrage .

All you have to do is to read the pages and pages of their Bismarck set to get the idea here . This hurts the hobby and us all , I am really to old to still tinker with PE but I remember life before .
.
Post Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2018 11:06 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Why not notch the protruding line on the plastic then? TBH I'd have just done that without a second thought.
Post Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2018 5:49 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Guest wrote:
Why not just cut some narrow slots in the seams? This is what modelling is about, problem solving.

First of all, you pay big bucks for these sets for a reason.
Second, you try cutting a notch on this part without destroying it. It can barely be handled without it bending all over the place.
Post Posted: Sun Apr 15, 2018 7:59 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Why not just cut some narrow slots in the seams? This is what modelling is about, problem solving.
Post Posted: Sun Apr 15, 2018 1:10 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
I've been concentrating on just getting the ship built and have not documented all the problems I keep running into, but this one really bugged me because it makes assembly very hard.
There are vertical seams that run all over the ship's hull. Pontos supplies you with a type of platform that goes around most of the ship. It is made out of stainless steel. Very nice looking. Very detailed.
The problem is, Pontos did not add "notches" in the platform to allow it to make contact with the hull. Instead, the only contact it makes is along this tiny seams. Most of the platform is left "floating" with gap between it and the hull. And since the part is made out of stainless steel, it is impossible to bend laterally without it distorting. Pontos makes some incredibly detailed parts, with all sorts of accommodations for the way the model is molded. I'm really bummed that they did not do this with these parts. It not only made the assembly very fragile in how it is glued, but also caused the brackets that support the platform to be useless since they cannot reach the hull without again, deforming them. Very bad oversight.
The picture shows just one of the many vertical seams, red arrows. The platform is marked with a black arrow.


Attachments:
seams.jpg
seams.jpg [ 52.96 KiB | Viewed 1516 times ]
Post Posted: Sat Apr 07, 2018 11:20 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Since Alan is interested, I will continue posting my findings.
I mentioned a wrong part count last night. Here it is:
Attachment:
boat windows2.jpg
boat windows2.jpg [ 81.13 KiB | Viewed 1638 times ]

As you can see, there are 5 parts 571 called for on each side of this lifeboat. Total 10 per boat. There are 2 of these boats. For a total of 20 parts.
This is what is supplied:
Attachment:
boat windows.jpg
boat windows.jpg [ 84.27 KiB | Viewed 1638 times ]

As you can see, there are only 18 of these parts supplied. So one of the boats will be short 2.
The error I mentioned is here:
Attachment:
bridge.jpg
bridge.jpg [ 143.14 KiB | Viewed 1638 times ]

There are 2 bridges on the Mikasa, referred to Pontos as the Front Bridge and the Back Bridge. Each bridge has its own picture page for assembly. In this picture you can see at the very top that this is the page for the REAR BRIDGE. The problem is that the small picture included on this page that has the red arrow pointing to it, is from the Front Bridge. While assembling the Front Bridge, I never saw that parts 302 and 303 went where indicated on this picture. I had to rip off the top of the bridge in order to be able to place those parts. VERY bad error.
I don't expect any comment by Pontos, much less fixes anymore.
Post Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2018 6:06 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Hi Alan!
How have you been?
Yep, I remember the Bismarck fiasco. I really think Pontos counts on making their money the minute something new is released, errors and all. Then rather than fix things, they move on to the next project and make a whole load of cash at the start. Rinse, repeat.
Since you're listening, I will keep posting.
Take care
Post Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2018 5:42 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Hi Tobori
Please don't stop posting...........l am sure l speak for many people in that we are very grateful for all your posts on here.
After the way we were all treated after the 1/200 Bismark fiasco when we literally rejigged/updated and corrected the instruction sheets for them - no thankyou's and they even resisted using the updated sheets initially on future sets to be sold.
It's a wonder that anybody bought anything under the Pontos label after that treatment.
Please continue to post - light hightedly l look for your updates!
Very best regards
Alan from UK
Post Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2018 7:35 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Tonight I found yet more errors and wrong part counts, but in view of the fact that Pontos has not commented, and for that matter anyone else, I'm done keeping track.
Bye bye.
Post Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2018 1:20 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Today I found 1 error and one question.
The question is, what part number is 5xx? I don't have enough covers that are similar to what I assume they are pointing at. They must have forgotten to actually include said part:
Attachment:
what is it.jpg
what is it.jpg [ 37.75 KiB | Viewed 1487 times ]

The error is here:
Attachment:
same number.jpg
same number.jpg [ 56.91 KiB | Viewed 1487 times ]

Notice how 2 completely different parts have the exact same part number. Glad I can read minds!
Post Posted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:26 pm
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Dang Pontos, I wish you would pay as much attention to your docs as you do to your PE. Here are these parts which are obviously related to the life rings:
Attachment:
life4.jpg
life4.jpg [ 29.04 KiB | Viewed 1624 times ]

NOWHERE on your instructions do I see any mention of where they are used. There is a small picture of what I assume is an "either or" choice???:
Attachment:
life2.jpg
life2.jpg [ 41.33 KiB | Viewed 1624 times ]

After scouring the pictures, I see a tiny little image of where it goes with nothing else.:
Attachment:
life3.jpg
life3.jpg [ 53.13 KiB | Viewed 1624 times ]

I know these sets are for "experts" but how hard can it be to just point it out a little bit? Why not take a little more time to perfect one PE set before rushing on to the next set, only to leave it full of omissions too?
Makes me wonder how many parts are going to be left on the frets that I'll have no idea whatsoever what to do with them. Not something I look forward to.
Post Posted: Mon Mar 19, 2018 2:02 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
For tonight little surprise, I found this problem.
Attachment:
part2.jpg
part2.jpg [ 113.19 KiB | Viewed 1753 times ]

I have placed arrows to show the parts that are called for. They are parts 467 and 468.

Now here is the fret where those parts are attached. I have circled them for clarity:
Attachment:
part.jpg
part.jpg [ 98.35 KiB | Viewed 1753 times ]

The pictures provided by Pontos online are low res, so it's hard to see the number, but number 468 is the one with the little holes. Notice that on the instructions there are 3 holes in part 468, but the part supplied only has 2, and the correct part is nowhere to be found on the fret. No big deal if it was just the number of holes, but the part is totally different size and will not fit on the model due to where the deck and other parts are located. I might have to use the kit part, which sucks because as you can see, I am leaving all the brass unpainted, and those 2 parts will have to be painted.
I wonder what tomorrow will bring....
Post Posted: Sat Mar 10, 2018 3:11 am
  Post subject:  Re: Pontosmodel 1/200 IJN Mikasa Detail Set  Reply with quote
Just as an example of the things I keep running into, this is the latest.
The 3 inch gun calls for part BRASS 06D, circled in red.
Attachment:
3-8-2018 8-50-01 PM.jpg
3-8-2018 8-50-01 PM.jpg [ 70.01 KiB | Viewed 1845 times ]

Yet on the part's diagram, not only does BRASS 06D not look at all like it does on the parts list, it's not even included in the kit, including the rest of the parts A, B C and E.
Attachment:
3-8-2018 8-49-25 PM.jpg
3-8-2018 8-49-25 PM.jpg [ 47.64 KiB | Viewed 1845 times ]

Fortunately, the gun parts are practicably invisible once installed in the kit. Only the shield and barrel are visible, so the base is not, but it's inexcusable that these things keep popping up. Pontos needs to improve their documentation and contents.. I love their sets. Great quality and lots of material, but I really hate running into stuff like this.
Post Posted: Fri Mar 09, 2018 12:04 am

All times are UTC - 6 hours [ DST ]


Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group