by sargentx » Wed Dec 03, 2014 12:00 pm
Okay,
So I bought Bondic and tried a number of tests comparing it to CA
Photo Etch to photo etch:
(edge glued to a flat piece of PE)
CA performed significantly better. The Bondic weld was weak and didn't adhere well to the flat piece. CA wins
(Flat to flat)
The UV light can't get to the Bondic that is deeper under the flat piece. It bonds along the edges though.
The bond is weak and far inferior to CA. CA wins
Photo Etch to plastic (polystyrene):
(PE edge to flat plastic)
Bondic is marginally better, but still nowhere close to the grip and strength of CA. Bondic is neat and elegant to use, but the strength just isn't there.
CA wins again
Plastic to plastic: (polystyrene)
(thick edge to flat piece)
No contest. CA wins hands down. The Bondic bond is weak. It's a joy to use, but just doesn't hold well.
As a filler:
Here is where bondic shines. You can fill a large gap with it, wipe the excess, get it right, then instantly harden it into a solid. This is a unique property that will be useful in certain situations.
It's rock hard, clear, and doesn't shrink.
For rigging:
A very tiny amount of bondic applied smoothly will grip a rigging line and hold it in place instantly once the UV light is applied. This is a nice feature and could be quite useful for rigging.
So there you go. Not the dream model material I was hoping for, but I REALLY like the gap filling properties and instant cure. It isn't ever going to compete with CA though for fine PE work.
Okay,
So I bought Bondic and tried a number of tests comparing it to CA
Photo Etch to photo etch:
(edge glued to a flat piece of PE)
CA performed significantly better. The Bondic weld was weak and didn't adhere well to the flat piece. CA wins
(Flat to flat)
The UV light can't get to the Bondic that is deeper under the flat piece. It bonds along the edges though.
The bond is weak and far inferior to CA. CA wins
Photo Etch to plastic (polystyrene):
(PE edge to flat plastic)
Bondic is marginally better, but still nowhere close to the grip and strength of CA. Bondic is neat and elegant to use, but the strength just isn't there.
CA wins again
Plastic to plastic: (polystyrene)
(thick edge to flat piece)
No contest. CA wins hands down. The Bondic bond is weak. It's a joy to use, but just doesn't hold well.
As a filler:
Here is where bondic shines. You can fill a large gap with it, wipe the excess, get it right, then instantly harden it into a solid. This is a unique property that will be useful in certain situations.
It's rock hard, clear, and doesn't shrink.
For rigging:
A very tiny amount of bondic applied smoothly will grip a rigging line and hold it in place instantly once the UV light is applied. This is a nice feature and could be quite useful for rigging.
So there you go. Not the dream model material I was hoping for, but I REALLY like the gap filling properties and instant cure. It isn't ever going to compete with CA though for fine PE work.