The Ship Model Forum

Ennui.

Hasegawa is re-releasing the IJN Mikasa with a figure of Admiral's Akiyama Saneyuki plus a poster of IJN Mikasa, link:
http://www.1999.co.jp/eng/10160938

Am in the progress of building the Mikasa 1/350 scale and have the Eduard PE set.
Am building it for the battle in Japanese waters and was wondering on the smoke stake tops, there are the plastic one's that raise up and the eduard ones that fit over the top of the stake, are the eduard ones ok for the Battle against the Russians!!!.

_________________
Cornwall UK

Give me couple of days Captain. I have photo of Mikasa which might answer your question but caption needs to be translated to check the date.

EDIT - ok, thanks to our forum member potchip I have translation already!

According to Mikasa's photo dated early February 1905 Eduard's caps are a bit too tall and WAY too square:

_________________
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken

Hi guys, i just picked up a Mikasa kit for a future build, but i was wondering if anyone knew how much work would be involved to convert it to a Majestic Class BB? how much commonality would there be between the ships?

cheers folks

_________________
"Wow, how'd you get it to work?"
"I ran a Physical Impulse Mechanical Stress Routine"
"Huh?"
"I kicked it."
"Ahh."

Ahh thanks for that DariusP, so its correct but needs to be less square, thanks thats a big help.

The picture tells it all .

_________________
Cornwall UK

Andy, this question has been asked before and the answer is: no commonality at all I am afraid.

_________________
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken

Hi dariusP mate.
Have altered the chimney stack, what do you think,is that better.

Done darker to see alteration better.

With more light.
Were there any other big changes for the Japan sea battle, have not found any so far.

_________________
Cornwall UK

You are almost there Captain. If you can make those caps a bit more curving upwards (convex) you will be there

By the looks of the vents around funnels I am guessing that you have "Battle of the Japan Sea" version of the kit? If so than you are set! Just don't use Eduard's fighting tops on masts or splinter shields for 3inch guns.

_________________
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken

Great thanks .

_________________
Cornwall UK

Seems I have changed me mind and want to do the earlier version against the Russians which ended up not so convincing for the Japanese till later.
With the splinter shields for 3in guns etc.
Were the chimney's the same then as I have some on the way,(not happy with the Eduard one,s)

_________________
Cornwall UK

Wash your mouth with soap Captain! Those are funnels not chimneys As for the earlier version on Mikasa... Funnels' cages were most likely the same BUT vents weren't (http://www.hlj.com/product/HSG40061) and, if you have later version of the kit, you will not have correct vents for the earlier version.

_________________
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken

Now have all the Information for both early and later.

The Funnel tops will be changed .

Thanks for your help, its comeing along nicly now. .




This is comeing along with most of the railings,steps etc.

_________________
Cornwall UK

Hello everybody,
I bought this kit several years ago, and it has been sitting on the top shelf waiting for inspiration for quite a while now. (battle of the japanese sea version)
The big question is what PE kit to use. Eduard, GMM or WEM? (sea masters guns will be ordered.)
I like the fact that the GMM kit is more "cut to size" regarding the railing and so on, but the WEM kit looks good aswell.
The Eduard kit is the cheapest among the lot, so its got that gooing for it, otherwise im mot to sure about the eduard kit
as far as WEM i have only used their 1:200 sovremenny PE kit and that one i liked.

Please help me out here as im lost right now...

// Claes

Hi Caes.

Well there both good WEM and Eduard, if your doing the Battle of the Japan sea well Eduard can do ether, so thats going for them plus the price.
Only you can decide, have you gone onto the WEM site, that might help your choice.
I think from looking at both etchings that the WEM should have been my choice.

I used the Eduard for my effort but had some other stuff from prev works on Japanease ships to help.

_________________
Cornwall UK

Hasegawa' set also is good but expensive. There is also a lot of alternatives for brass barrels.

well as it turned out i ordered the GMM set and the masters guns for her. i know that there apparently is an issue with the stands for the dingis but apart from that i just liked the look of it.

hopefully i will be starting the build next month

New to the forum. I was wondering if anyone could shed some light or build thoughts/review on the Seal 1/700 Mikasa. I am awaiting the arrival of my Ebay purchase and am looking forward to seeing how good the kit is (or isn't). Thoughts on detail, accuracy, available detail sets etc. Any input would be appreciated.

Jim Johnston

_________________
Jim Johnston
http://jimsfigs.blogspot.com

Great quality, and for the accuracy the only problem that I noticed was the small guns dosent look convincing, and you have to pay a lot of care in the instructions. Compered with the 1/350 by Hesgawa model, I think the Seals model is better suited for an early IJN Mikasa rather than a later period(it offers only the early type ventilators).
Fit is great btw(the hull is split in two).

Only the Japan Sea Hasegawa model - the Yellow Sea kit comes with the early masts and ventilators.

_________________
De quoi s'agit-il?