PeterE wrote:
Good list.
I'd add one, Neptune's Inferno by J. Hornfischer. It's a most riveting book on the Guadalcanal naval battles. Although you can't compare it to any other book -after all authors have different styles, focus, etc, this one is one that will stand the test of time.
Guadalcanal was a special type of battle, fought in close confines, and at night. Horrific combat, I now believe that naval fighting is the worst form of warfare.
Hornfischer has achieved the right balance between telling the story as seen from the top, with all the personality conflicts amid the brass and the experiences of the ordinary sailor, which were no ordinary, let me tell you.
Good, thogh few and too small, photos compliment the book.
Got
Neptune's Inferno on loan from the local library as a result of reading this thread. Pretty much agree with what PeterE says, above. For my part I find it a bit of a ponderous read cover-to-cover. I admit to skipping ahead to find and read about First Battle of Guadalcanal. However, there are enough gems of information scattered throughout the read to keep me seeing what the next page brings.
What I do think the books lacks is a good fold out map of the South Pacific *1942* like the book has inside its front and back covers. To me, having a map handy makes it easier follow the flow of events.
I doubt I'll buy the book as a shelf reference. Having it available for checkout from the library meets my needs (except I can't make personal notes in the margins). I do recommend it for reading.