RNfanDan wrote:
It has other drawbacks. Its WW2-era coverage, in particular, is rather lacking for information. The copy I bought a couple years ago breezes past this period with about the same thoroughness as a cake recipe deals with oven technology. The better part (in both quality and quantity) dealt with her postwar changes and career. I rate this book as about equal to the AOTS Bismarck, though for entirely different reasons.
If you're a Cold War RN aficionado, it's a better deal.
IMHO the definitive Illustrious-class carriers book has yet to be written.
I agree there

. Although I value my copy highly as one of the few good RN Carrier reference books, the lack of WWII history, war time changes and additions along with the small couple of pages of photos was a great let down. She formed part of the core of Britain's naval power in WWII. That surely is a much more interesting period than the post war changes and history. Still, take what you can get I guess. Where is the large reference book on HMS Ark Royal? I wish Britain's Carriers attracted 1/10 of the interest the BBs do. After all, it was the Carriers which gave the RN the edge. Taranto, Bismarck, Matapan, Malta convoys and ferry runs. Britain's contribution to the Pacific campaign. The small carriers ASW work from 1943 on. Simple fear of RN Carriers made the Italians run for port.
Bob B.