The Ship Model Forum

The other day, a modeler with very fond memories of building this kit as a kid, and several of the 1/500 Renwal kits of that time, sent me a message asking if I would rescale some 3D-printed designs specifically for the classic Revell Missouri (and, of course, New Jersey and Wisconsin boxings!) in 1/535 scale, the Revell Cold War Essex class kits in 1/530 scale, and Renwal Shangri La , Ticonderoga and USS King kits in 1/500. He had collected some of the kits he built in his youth and intended to build them again.

Some of the rescalings are done, more will be soon, and are available here:
http://www.shapeways.com/shops/Model_Mo ... +Ships&s=0

Whatever the Missouri kit's issues may be, there is a nostalgia for them and continued interest in them that surpasses their shortcomings, going on 60+ years.

Gold Medal Models has made PE sets for the Revell Essexes and Midways for years.

Now, you can get some 3D-printed parts for them, too.

Photos courtesy Scalemates.com

_________________
Have fun, Monkey around.™

-Steve L.

Complete catalog: - https://www.model-monkey.com/
Follow Model Monkey® on Facebook: - https://www.facebook.com/modelmonkeybookandhobby

Hi

I have always wondered what the difference was between the Renwal and Revell Essex kits was...never seen two at the same time to compare them. Are they two totally different molds? Does the Renwal hull also the viking ship like keel?

thanks
Uwe

PS: Which one is the better bases for an accurat model...if any?

They are both great kits.

The Renwal kit is larger, being 1/500. Revell's is 1/530. IMHO, the Revell kit is better detailed but both look good in overall shape.

For accuracy, the answer depends on which Essex you want to build. The most noticeable differences between the ships are the shape of the hurricane bow and the the bridge window configuration as well as the location of the aft, starboard elevator. It's been a while since I had the Renwal kit in hand but if I remember correctly, the Renwal kit has a hurricane bow shape better suited to Lexington. If you want to build an accurate Lexington or Shangri La, go Renwal, otherwise Revell.

I don't remember what the Renwal keel looked like but hopefully someone here with the kit can check for us.

Oriskany has a rather unusual hurricane bow shape, being flat near the top with a distinct "knuckle" in the shape of a shallow "smile". Neither kit's bow is right for Oriskany out of the box, but with some basic scratch-building skills, either of the kits' bows could be modified. See:

Revell's classic Iowa class kits still hold a place in my heart. It's good to see them still around.

_________________
Have fun, Monkey around.™

-Steve L.

Complete catalog: - https://www.model-monkey.com/
Follow Model Monkey® on Facebook: - https://www.facebook.com/modelmonkeybookandhobby

Hi group!

I know this is an old topic, but I stumbled on it the other day and it prompted me to pull out this very kit from the deep stash and make a project of seeing what a little TLC can tease out of it.

I think that declaring this kit over is a bit premature. There are certainly better kits out there, but generally priced a lot higher. I know I built 5 of these when I was a kid, and then played with them a lot. If I were buying a model kit for a kid, I wouldn't buy one of the expensive ones, but would definitely look at this kit because a kid needs one they can build and feel good about, and one that isn't too expensive to play with.

The kit I'm building from was one I bought for my son to use as a reference guide in a 3-D modelling project for school. The only enhancements I've purchased are some 1:550 railing and some anchor chain. I'll be scratch-building a few refinements, but most of the project will rely upon the detail extant in the model itself.

I'll post pics when complete.

_________________
The most attractive project, to me, is the one that I've just heard someone say can't be done.