The Ship Model Forum

Different parts layout and PE included, but otherwise looks the same as the Revell 1/350 upon first viewing.

_________________
Thomas E. Johnson

http://www.youtube.com/user/ThomasEJohnson

Did anyone see Trumpeter has announced the Tirpitz in 1/200 scale this year! I've been hoping they would do the Tirpitz.

That’s one I’ll take.

_________________
Thomas E. Johnson

http://www.youtube.com/user/ThomasEJohnson

Question regarding Bismarck's signal yards: during the Denmark Strait battle, the order for "open fire" was "jot dora" - assuming this was sent via signal flags in addition to wireless and/or signal lamps, which yard would the signals have been raised on? The forward yards just above the bridge that are angled towards the bow, or the yards on the mainmast?

_________________
De quoi s'agit-il?

Hello everybody,

on the Bismarck on the spring of 1941, just before sailing for Op. Rheinubung, there was a new small platform added aside ( one on each side ) of the Admiral bridge.

This small platform was made in order to serve the small signal lamp as well as a new position for the sailor making flag signals from a dedicated elevated position at the corner of the platform itself.

I assume that the signal's from the Bismarck to the Prinz Eugen were made from that position on the Bismarck port side.

Basically doing the opposite of what you can see on the attached photo being done from Prinz Eugen to Bismarck on this photo on April 19th, 1941 in the baltic sea doing some training.

Bye, Antonio Bonomi

Thanks Antonio, that helps. Tricky to pull off in 1/700, though!

_________________
De quoi s'agit-il?

I agree. Unless memory fails me, the war diaries really don't say how the signals were sent/received, but signal lamp makes the most sense simply because of their respective positions; the lamps should have been visible from PG (Prinz Eugen) even from her position well ahead of BS (Bismarck). Of course, I suppose coded signals via wireless would also have worked since they already knew they were sighted by four enemy ships (and soon to be one aircraft). Of course, BS would go on to use her wireless a bit too much in the coming days...but thank goodness(for us) that she did.

_________________
Frank Allen
H.M.S. Hood Association
http://www.hmshood.org.uk

I consider that very unlikely. The new platform is too close to the admirals bridge and there would have been a risk that the signal is partially covered. In the 3D-picture you've posted there is the same small platform for signals (at the right of the red circle) like on Prinz Eugen. It's an much more exposed position and therefore well visible from another ship.

However, I don't think that the signal was made by flag semaphores. It's more likely that the flag signal was flying on the main- or foremast. There was in any case a separate flag line on the main mast just for battle signals.

For a beginner in models, which 1/350 Tirpitz and aftermarket set affords the best build process and quality? I'm deciding mainly between Tamiya and Academy as they seem the most beginner friendly brands.

Maybe Revell, but I don't want that platinum edition Tirpitz because it has extensive frets of PE and brass gun barrels. I'm not looking for that level of hyper detail.

Just want a decent plastic kit and a basic aftermarket PE set - ideally the less frets, the better, as I struggle with PE and wouldn't want to mess up on the Tirpitz.

_________________
BUILDING

1/350 British pre-dreadnought battleship HMS Agamemnon

The Tamiya and Academy are identical kits asides from potential molding quality and the display stand, so you don't really have to choose there.

To keep the PE simple, look for some of the older brands, like White Ensign Models, Tom's Modelworks, and Gold Model Models. Of these, the Tom's set is the most barebones, as there are additional frets you can buy separately, and it doesn't include parts dedicated to Bismarck like the other two which combines both ships' unique parts into the same fret(s).

_________________
De quoi s'agit-il?

Are there any in-detail reviews of a new Trumpeter 1/350 Bismarck and 1/200 Scharnhorst?

Both in German, both from the same German ship modeling website.

Bismarck review: http://www.modellmarine.de/index.php?op ... tid=69:tru

Scharnhorst preview: http://www.modellmarine.de/index.php?op ... tid=69:tru

_________________
Martin

"Tomorrow is the most important thing in life. Comes into us at midnight very clean. It's perfect when it arrives and it puts itself in our hands. It hopes we've learned something from yesterday." John Wayne

Ship Model Gallery

Many thanks Martin, exactly what I was looking for, very helpful links.
Bismarck seems to be a a visible (but no major) improvement over already very good Revell kit.
Big new 1/200 Scharnhorst is suffering from a bit of unexpected shortcomings, but overall very nice presentation of that majestic, elegantly designed German battleship.

That discussion about Scharnhorst class (battlecruiser or battleship) is as old as Universe, and I am well aware of controversies regarding that matter.
Have no intention to add to that discussion, fell free to call it as you wish, does not matter much, Scharnhorst remains one of the most beautiful warships ever built.

Hola

For my friend José María Rico, (http://www.kbismarck.com/
http://www.kbismarck.org/forum/index.php) I have done this:



https://lnkd.in/dEQMN9J



If you follow the link and click on the image you can download a higher resolution version.

Regards

Is there finally a definitive general agreement about Bismarck camouflage scheme during The Battle of the Denmark Strait and used colors?

There is a lot of contradicting information to be found across the web, confusing variations of used shades of dark and light gray on finished models, was waterline black or black-gray, what is correct shade of hull red, Swastikas over-painted or not, false painted waves, turret tops color etc ... so, please, help.

There are plenty of photos available on the internet searches that show the false bow wave still present when the ship was photographed leaving Norway. It stands to reason that it would not have been over painted during a high speed sea run to enter the Atlantic. The swastikas are present on the wreck. I am pretty sure I read that they were covered over with canvas.

The swastikas are visible on the wreck, but there are streaks throughout that can be interpreted as faded grey paint or the wood underneath. Faded paint would seem plausible given the rushed job it'd have to have been if it was used.

_________________
De quoi s'agit-il?

Hello

Obviously, there is not a definitive solution to the issues raised. At Kbismarck there are some of the best Bismarck experts.

We cannot affirm that the scheme is 100% correct, but it is very plausible. Colors have been defined according to RAL specifications and have been lighted by 25% due to the scale effect.

The drawing will be updated if we can find more information. Stay tuned at KBismarck.

Regards

Thanks for reply.
Please, could you provide links to photographs used as a reference for making that drawing?