Calling all Borodino (Бородино) class (Tsushima 1905) fans

Battleships and Battlecruisers of all nations and eras.
BB and BC.

Moderators: BB62vet, MartinJQuinn, Timmy C, Gernot, Olaf Held, Dan K, HMAS, ModelMonkey

Post Reply
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

Unfortunately, Online-translator has not helped me to understand sense of a question.... :scratch:
I believe, these photos can appear useful.
It's SLAVA, 1/100 R/C model from Belorussia.

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hi Darius
I'm hoping someone out there has better photos that can prove something either way...

I'd like to clear up any misinterpretations of my draughtmaship.

The blue lines are only solid to make it clear what I was talking about, I hope no-one else thinks I mean a solid beam... I did mean a hollow rectangular beam. I coloured in the areas I thought could correspond to the masts and what is shown on the plans is square. From the photos it is a rectangle, 1-1'6" (30-45cm )wide and 2-3' (60-90 cm) deep.

Okay

2 Ahhh, interesting, I had a look and Orel's boat boom did not have to clear the square base on the funnel. The the pivot must have been above deck height as the boat boom can be seen in a horizontal position above the square base in photographs. Another little difference.. The blocks may still have needed to be further apart as the funnel is a bit wider, but actually the forward boats in Orel seem to be a little further outboard than Borodino in some photos. Maybe it's because the boom couldn't get far enough inboard, who knows, another mystery :-)

3 I'm not sure if you mean a) solid = 4 walls or b) solid = filled with iron/steel. The latter b) I agree is is far too heay and yes a) is pretty heavy too, but not out of the quetion I think. The L idea could be correct (if there are any masts at all) but if it is, then it would be like this. But I'd like to estabish if they exist or not before trying to define their shape

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... mg&thumb=4

4 Some of the walls are very visible I think, where the arrows are
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... t2&thumb=4

They are in a lot of shadow because of the deck wings above them and possibly shadows from the "masts" as well - if they exist!!
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

LOL Kronma it's not the Slava, Suvorov or Aleks.III we have problems with but Borodino and Orel. Have you got any idea how those boom supports we can see in Slava's model looked like in Borodino and Orel?

BTW what is this "contraption" behind Slava's conning tower in the 4th foto from the top? Auxiliary steam engine of some sort?
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

DariusP wrote:BTW what is this "contraption" behind Slava's conning tower in the 4th foto from the top? Auxiliary steam engine of some sort?
It is the steam winch for risе of the boats.
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Hello Kronma
I have had problems with online translators too. I will try to write in short sentences, it's better I think.

I am proposing that Borodino could have had a mast to handle the boat boom. I think it may have looked like your photo of the St. Petersburg model, except

1 the mast is thinner.
2 the chart room walls go round the outside of the mast.

Photo 1 is a simplified scheme of my proposal.
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... xu&thumb=4

Photo 2 is your photo of the St Petersburg model. Below is the same photo I have drawn lines on to explain what I intend...

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... mn&thumb=4
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... ew&thumb=4

Photo 3 is zvezda's model. There is no connection between the top part and the bottom part in the model. they are outlined in paler blue to make it easier to see. I am wondering if there should be.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... js&thumb=4

Photo 4 is your photo of Borodino being built. notice that the man beside the captain's cabin is either wearing a big black hat or there is something black on the wall. The captain's cabin wall seems to bend just before this black object, so I don't think it is part of the cabin. I think it is part of a mast, like the model. The chart house walls are all white so either the mast stops at the deck above or it is behind the cabin wall.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... 2j&thumb=4

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... sb&thumb=4

The reason why I think this are

1 the captain's cabin always seemed to be wider at the back than it should be when projecting lines.

2 there seems to be a continuous line from the base of the pulley at the top of the superstructure, the back of the captain's cabin (which is too wide) and the chart house.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... o0&thumb=4

please remember the top is shaded by the pulley.

3 there is a mention on Borodino plans of squares where the boom attaches and they are either side of the captain's cabin.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... lm&thumb=4

my proposal on this plan
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... lv&thumb=4

or

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... g2&thumb=4


But I cannot find any evidence that the masts existed on the real ship.

I am wondering if anyone else has looked at this?

Thanks
John
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

http://img81.imageshack.us/img81/5160/o ... l01up6.jpg
John, look at this photo: if Orel's booms didn't clear funel base, didn't they have to clear the forked steam pipe behind the funnel (arrow 01)? And look at, admittedly not very distinctive, shape pointed by arrow 02....
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

DariusP wrote: John, look at this photo...
Very interesting photo! :smallsmile:
At the left it is visible BORODINO.
The height of a funnel and the top part of "mast" is well visible.
The bottom part of a "mast" is closed by a shadow.

Image
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

cerberusjf wrote:my proposal on this plan
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... lv&thumb=4
John, I think, that this variant - correct.
cerberusjf wrote:Photo 4 is your photo of Borodino being built. notice that the man beside the captain's cabin is either wearing a big black hat or there is something black on the wall. The captain's cabin wall seems to bend just before this black object, so I don't think it is part of the cabin. I think it is part of a mast, like the model.
I too so think. :smallsmile:

Image

Image

I hope, these photos will appear useful. :smallsmile:

Image
Last edited by KRONMA on Mon Nov 12, 2007 4:53 pm, edited 3 times in total.
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

KRONMA wrote:Very interesting photo! :smallsmile:
At the left it is visible BORODINO.
The height of a funnel and the top part of "mast" is well visible.
The bottom part of a "mast" is closed by a shadow.
Yes Kronma, both John and me were talking about this photo as a possible evidence that such a "mast" existed on Borodino but there is just not enough detail there to consider it as real proof.
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

[quote="KRONMA"]
I too so think. :smallsmile:
[quote]

Thank you very much Kronma!! :-) I think the mast is logical, there doesn't appear to be any other vertical support.

Here are a couple more photos for evidence..

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... yt&thumb=4

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... o0&thumb=4


I see you have posted much better photos. Thank you again!!! :big_grin:
The photo on the bottom left lets me see much more clearly :-) The whole mast is clear to see I think!!! The pattern seems to be consistent in all the photographs too.

When I was trying to find evidence for my proposal, I was quite excited when I looked at the photo of Borodino fitting out in the background. I think it is very interesting that it should be consistent with other photos in showing something that could be masts. But as Darius says, it was not clear enough to be conclusive.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... wm&thumb=4

and with the masts in blue.
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... 2c&thumb=4

And thank you again for all your help, it is really appreciated. Ideas can only be good if there is evidence to back them up.

The model of Slava is incredible. I didn't kn ow it was radio controlled too!!! I want it!! :-)


Hi Darius,
thanks for the photo of Orel. I don't know what happened by the steam pipes. The boom seems to go very near in this photograph, see "1" in this photograph.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... pt&thumb=6

You can maybe make out that the boom is above the level of the square base.

If you look at the "2" in my photo I think you can make out the back wall of the navigation bridge. The windows are consistent with going from side to side and are not in the correct arrangement for the starboard wall of the navigation bridge. :-)

From your photo I can see some differences between Orel and Borodino, for example the width of the cabin behind the navigation bridge. Is this the captain's cabin in Orel too? I have had a look at your "2" and it looks like where the pulley is attached. I don't think the shape of the top necessarily has to be the same shape as the mast. It could be the same, it could be different. Also it is Orel and not Borodino and could be a different shape from Borodino. It is a different shape in the Orel plan than the Borodino photograph. I think it is better to take each ship individually... :-)
Thanks as always
John
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

cerberusjf wrote:I think the mast is logical, there doesn't appear to be any other vertical support.
Yes, it so! Also it is the main argument!
I wished to tell the same, but the translator could not translate correctly... :smallsmile:
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Nice one Kronma! The bottom left photo of Borodino from your post is the clearest indication so far of a mast on this ship ( like John said: one ship at a time :eyebrows: ). Few things to point out:
1- mast runs outside of both Captain's Cabin and Charthouse (so both seems to be of the same width) but, in my opinion, does not touch the walls of those cabins;
2- width of Captain's Cabin seems very close to the width of Navigation Cabin;
3- exact shape of the mast still escapes me....it looks like it is made of "]" beam but with (if you pardon me the expression) the side closest to the cabins wider than the other and, above the compass platform, sides taper towards the wider face , but again not symetrically so.... Something like this: http://i110.photobucket.com/albums/n96/ ... dino01.jpg Strange or what?

Questions, questions, questions.... :big_grin:
Last edited by DariusP on Tue Nov 13, 2007 4:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hi Darius,
Thanks for the points.

I am very happy for the chart house wall to go inside of the masts. I thought they could go round the outside because I was told that the walls of the charthouse were curved. For this to be true, the back wall would have to curve to meet the outer, outboard edge of the mast. The only place for a curve I could see is where I have circled.

http://www.mediafire.com/upload_complet ... 43b4yncn0b

I can�t see a possible curve anywhere else along this wall. Thanks to Kronma�s photo I can see the circled area is not a curve, it is a corner.

http://radikal.ru/F/i050.radikal.ru/071 ... 4.jpg.html

I don�t really understand why you are saying the walls of the cabin don�t go all the way to the mast�.The walls we can see in the photograph are of the cabins and chart house, aren�t they? They go all the way to the masts. I can�t see any gaps between the mast and the walls, especially the chart room. 


After seeing Kronma�s photos I�m more inclined to a square or a slightly rectangular box section mast made of steel. The mast appears to be walled on all sides at the top, like the model. From this photo..

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... mj&thumb=4
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Check my edited post John. I am not actually sure that Captain's Cabin and Charthouse aren't touching the mast. It was only my impression. And walls certainly weren't curved. I thought that corners where walls meet could have been.
Last edited by DariusP on Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Hi Darius
okay, unfortunately I can't update my post as I forgot to log in... The tops are an unusal shape, difficult to make out. It would't be half as much fun if it were easy :-) My guess was that it was like this...
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... 0x&thumb=4
Unlined to compare
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... l0&thumb=4

The red lines are stanchions, blue the mast. It's confusing!!! I'm not sure I got the inboard part of the mast top right, there seems to be something around that stanchion.. :scratch:
Mmmmhhh!!!!!![/url]
Last edited by cerberusjf on Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Ok John I probably mistook stanchion for a part of the mast. We seems to agree on general outline but your drawing makes more sense except inboard wall is still wider than outboard one.....Very confusing! :big_grin:

PS. There is a rope close to the stanchion in question but I have looked at it closely and IMO it doesn't alter the main outlines of the mast....
Guest

Post by Guest »

Maybe this is a bit closer??
http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... tg&thumb=4

A close-up shot would be good!!!

I remember seeing a close-up of Orel's mast top. It was among the photos taken after her capture. There was a Japanese sailor there too. Has anyone else seen this? Am I jumping ahead??
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

As a slight diversion. :-)

Here is a copyright-free downloadable book that might be of interest.

It is called "From Libau to Tsushima ; a narrative of the voyage of Admiral Rojdestvensky's fleet to eastern seas, including a detailed account of the Dogger Bank incident" by Evgenii Sigizmondovich Politovskii, 1874-1905.

It is in English and can be downloaded in several fomats..

http://www.archive.org/details/fromliba ... 00poliiala
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

Anonymous wrote:I remember seeing a close-up of Orel's mast top. It was among the photos taken after her capture. There was a Japanese sailor there too.
Perhaps, this photos? :eyebrows:

Image

Image
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

DariusP wrote: Questions, questions, questions....
It seems to me, that logic of reasonings such:
Whether the top detail of model differs from the original?
Let's compare:

Image

Yes, this details are similar (are identical on model and on the original).
Little bit other form of a rack in the original - more simple, without radius.
Means, and other details of this element of model, are similar to the original.
That is, racks ("masts") were such, as on model - closed, the square form.
IMHO, certainly. :smallsmile:
Post Reply

Return to “Battleships”