Calling all Borodino (Бородино) class (Tsushima 1905) fans

Battleships and Battlecruisers of all nations and eras.
BB and BC.

Moderators: BB62vet, MartinJQuinn, Timmy C, Gernot, Olaf Held, Dan K, HMAS, ModelMonkey

Post Reply
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Ok.... so in photo 2 we basically seems to have something like that: http://i110.photobucket.com/albums/n96/ ... /BOR02.jpg My sketch isn't very accurate (I have no idea if the angle was like in Kronma's inset from original drawings or if it went all the way to the deck like in the model) but I think it gets the general outlines? What bothers me is that, in such a high resolution photo, I can't see anything even vaguely looking like a extension of a mast below the Compass Platform! And why something looking suspiciously like masts are visible in plan view drawing of Borodino but not in Kronma's insets? Now you two, please tell me just why I shouldn't worry about that? :big_grin:
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Hi Kronma,
thanks for the photos, but no, it's not any of them. I remember it being photographed from the compass platform, looking over the port side. It struck me because I hadn't ever seen it before. I have had a quick look but I can't find it anywhere yet. :scratch:

Hi Darius,



I have done a quick sketch to let you see what I think.



http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... a5&thumb=6



The proportions height:width for the mast above the compass platform are 2.55:1. I have tried to outline the mast above compass platform level in blue. I thought there could be a deck support beam that runs in front of the mast (wrt the viewer). I have outlined this area in white. But now I'm not sure. I haven't found evidence of deck beams in other photos, so perhaps something else is happening. I think it could still be deck beams though. All the other decks seem to have them.

There is a piece of deck furniture in the foreground, outlined in purple. This would leave only the area circled in red where the mast can be seen. There are subtle changes in shading where the mast would be, but it is difficult to be certain what is happening. One thing we don't know is the thickness of the deck.



I guess this is because it is in the shade from the compass platform and deck furniture around that makes it too difficult to see what is going on. Well that's my best guess!! :big_grin: Also I think the high resolution will only apply to well lit areas of the photo. Less well lit areas will not have long enough exposure to have as good resolution. Well that's my guess!!





And why is it missing from the inset plan? I haven't got a clue I'm afraid. I could say that sometimes things are missed from plans. It also depends on what the plan is showing. Perhaps it is not intended to be a straightforward profile view of Borodino. But IMHO what is more important is that the drawing of the mast top matches the photos and the masts can be seen quite clearly in other photos I think. :smallsmile:



Photographs have some advantages over plans. If there is a good, clear photograph that categorically disproves the existence of these masts on Borodino, I'd very much welcome it. But it would need to clearly show it.





NB this photo is actually a rougher draught of one that didn't upload properly, the proportions are a bit bigger than 2.55:1 but the end result is the same..
Last edited by cerberusjf on Sat Nov 17, 2007 7:35 am, edited 2 times in total.
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

LOL John, we can work out thickness of platform's decks by looking at original inboard view of Orel. From other sources I know the measurements of searchlights, compass column ect. I can give you later an exact figure but while the main deck was pretty thick platform's decks were quite thin.
cerberusjf wrote:Also I think the high resolution will only apply to well lit areas of the photo. Less well lit areas will not have long enough exposure to have as good resolution
That's not quite true. With Shadow/Highlight adjustment in Photoshop I can actually get details from photographs of subjects that aren't well lit but this photo isn't one of them. Oh well, a pity.....

I also think that I MIGHT have worked out why our mast could be missing from inset provided by Kronma. His inset in taken from inboard view and if you look at inboard view of Orel you will see that is shows the boom and reel from the other side (port) of the ship. So whatever there is, is hidden by Captain's Cabin and Charthouse.

I agree about advantages of photos over plans. Look at the original drawings of Suvorov and Aleks.III and see that the braces, which photograps clearly show as supporting booms' masts, do not connect to those masts at all. Would have been very misleading if somebody was using just the original drawings. But I am still filing a "minority report" that, even with the photos kindly provided by Kronma, I am still reserving my opinion as to how boom masts in Borodino and Orel were constructed. IMO the arrowhead arrangements seen in original drawings of Orel (plan view) still can't be discounted.

Ok now, where are the winches to work the forward booms? We know that there are two to the rear of the aft bridge to work the two rear booms but where are the winches to work the forward ones?
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hi Darius,

I think you're right about the plan inset, that's my guess too. I think they show the complete compass platform, then a section through the cabin. But without the plan, it is difficult to see.

I tried your picture gain (thanks again for the hirez pictures) and I still end up with a bit of a gap. Again I've outlined the mast top in blue from the point where I think it meets the deck up. I estimated this by taking the height of the stanchion + height of the deck side = the height of the mast above the compass platform.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... sj&thumb=4

There are dark patches that seem to correspond to the mast. I have also outlined in blue.

The lower part of the msts would be hidden by the deck furniture outlined in purple.

But there is a problem. There is a gap between the upper blue lines and lower blue lines, where I put a red arrow. I don't know why there is this gap!! I did think it could be a deck support. There seemed to be a pattern on the underside. But I checked other photos (kronma Borodino/Orel, upper left) and there are no deck supports!!!! So it's not that.... Another theory is that there are supports but there was a "skin" put over them... unlikely but I'm getting desperate!!! Or that my drawing is out.

There is also something I've outlined in green. I don't know what that is!!!

But I think that it could still show the masts, just not as clearly as I would have liked..

At present I am pretty convinced that Borodino had masts very much like the model. Orel is a different story, I am not sure what goes on with her.

I can understand about the arrowhead arrangement. It appears in all the plans I've seen so far. But I haven't seen it in a photo.


Now for your next question, where are the winches... you took the words from my mouth!! from the model, the rope goes down to the conning tower platform. I thought it would go through to the deck below and to some winches there. But I can't see any on the Orel deck plan. There seems to be pulleys at about the right spot. I have outlined them in pink. But they don't seem to lead anywhere.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... om&thumb=4

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... 2m&thumb=4
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

Number 19 - are mechanisms of rise of 47-mm of shells on bridges.
Square, where figures - mechanical submission.
Square without figures - emergency, spare, manual submission. :smallsmile:
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Well, I learned something new today: I knew that number 19 were elevators for 47mm ammunition but had no idea what were those bits and pieces which seemed fixed to the superstructure wall. Now I know: emergency manual gear for ammunition elevators! Thanks Kronma! :thumbs_up_1:

John, let me explain why I don't discount arrowhead arrangements for the boom masts even in Borodino: Kronma's photos are great but shadows and perspective can be deceptive and there just isn't enough detail to be sure of the shapes we are seeing. Look at this photo: http://img118.imageshack.us/img118/4303/mast01ft7.jpg and imagine, even if just for the discussion's sake, that the red outline is one of the sides on the "arrowhead" while the yellow one is the "shaft".
Guest

Post by Guest »

KRONMA wrote:Number 19 - are mechanisms of rise of 47-mm of shells on bridges.
Square, where figures - mechanical submission.
Square without figures - emergency, spare, manual submission. :smallsmile:
Thanks for the reply Kronma.

Can I check that I have understood properly?

In this picture

http://www.mediafire.com/upload_complet ... fwzrlnj4tl

1 is Square, where figures - mechanical submission.

2 is Square without figures - emergency, spare, manual submission.

Have I understood correcty?


It corresponds to the area circled on the model. Is that correct?


http://www.mediafire.com/upload_complet ... mynjvyrjc2


And do you know if "3" on the photo is anything to do with the raising the boom for the forward boats?

Thanks for your help
John
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

And this is the shell hoist for the 47mm guns circled in this photograph of Borodino?

Thanks
John

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... lx&thumb=4 :smallsmile:
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

John, the answer is "yes" in two cases and "no" in two others :big_grin:

The marked areas on the model and photo are indeed hoists. But, on the drawing, both "1" and "2" form one hoist while "3" is a manual, emergency gear.
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

Anonymous wrote: Can I check that I have understood properly?
In this picture....
Unfortunately, links have not opened. :scratch:
cerberusjf wrote:And this is the shell hoist for the 47mm guns circled in this photograph of Borodino?
Yes. :smallsmile:
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Thanks for the reply Kronma.

Here is the link, I am not sure why the previous one stopped working

The plan
picture boatmastwinchlined2

This is what I understood you meant.


1 is Square, where figures - mechanical submission.

2 is Square without figures - emergency, spare, manual submission.


1 and 2 are in the green square (in case the link does not work again) :smallsmile:


The model
photo borodinoshellhoistlined

Darius has let me know that my 1 and 2 are the mechanical hoist and my 3 (in the pink square) is the manual hoist. I have to admit I am interested to learn this!!!

Thanks
John
Last edited by cerberusjf on Mon Feb 18, 2008 5:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

cerberusjf wrote: Darius has let me know that my 1 and 2 are the mechanical hoist and my 3 (in the pink square) is the manual hoist.
No, it not so. :smallsmile:
Number 3 has no attitude to manual hoist.
Manual hoist was vertical, approximately, as in this figure.

Image

Besides pay attention, that Mechanical hoist was above, than on model.

Image
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Thanks kronma,

That is very interesting about the manual hoist!!!!


the photo of the real ship that I uploaded previously seems to be working again.

http://www.mediafire.com/imageview.php? ... lx&thumb=4

and again on photobucket.. :smallsmile:

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... 2lined.jpg

So is it correct?

1 is the mechanical hoist and
2 is the manual hoist?

in this photo?

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... lined2.jpg


And these are the 47mm shell hoists in the aft superstructure?

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... tlined.jpg
Thanks
John
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

cerberusjf wrote: So is it correct?...
in this photo?
I think, what yes.
At least, so it is written on the drawing and to specifications.
cerberusjf wrote: And these are the 47mm shell hoists in the aft superstructure?
Yes, it's the 47-mm shell hoists.
Pay attention, that the mine of manual submission of 47-mm shells was used as an emergency exit from a magazines - there the ladder is established...

Image
Last edited by KRONMA on Sat Nov 17, 2007 8:42 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

About a detail number 3... :smallsmile:
I believe, that it was used for rise of boats.
Approximately, here so:

Image
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Many thanks kronma,

I find all these details fascinating!!

What I meant by
is this correct?
was "is this what you wanted us to understand?"

I think it is correct (what is on the real ship) too. We may never know with absolute certainty :smallsmile:

I just wanted to make sure I understood you properly. :thumbs_up_1:

But I see a small problem.

Where does the rope go after "3"? It has to go forward and it has to go to a winch at some point. The only thing I can see would be the capstan. Would the use the capstan to raise the boats? The rope could go under the 6" turret. But do you know if it was like that? Or was there another winch that we can't see?


There is also another problem I think. Shouldn't there be two ropes? One to raise and lower the boom and one to raise and lower the boat/hook? Maybe Borodino's boom was permanently at an angle, but Orel's boom must have raised and lowered.

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... lined3.jpg

Many thanks
John
Last edited by cerberusjf on Sat Nov 17, 2007 10:18 am, edited 3 times in total.
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Kronma, in your last post you use inboard view of Borodino and plan view of Orel.
I am not really sure if details like ammunition hoists and handling of the boats were similar in both ships. I am sure that original drawings don't always match with photograps. For example: in Orel's original drawings, mechanical and manual hoists (emergency escape) are two shafts arranged side by side. I don't have any close enough shots of Orel to compare how it looked in a real ship but in photograph of Borodino's bridge it is only a single shaft!

But even if boat handling arrangement were similar in both ships I agree with John: t looks to me that if no.3 was indeed a part of boat handling mechanism there have to be a winch somewhere even if to rise the boats and to swing the boom over the ship's side.
BTW John very interesting question about lowering and raising of Borodino's forward booms. There was a permanent support for those booms in lowered position which, I assume, wouldn't be necessary if they were permanently raised? On the other hand, I checked all my photos of this ship and I haven't seen one with forward booms down and trying to assess if in all the photos booms were raised to the same height is extremly tricky....
Last edited by DariusP on Sat Nov 17, 2007 1:42 pm, edited 1 time in total.
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Hi Darius
I was wondering if the manual hoist/escape ladder were not in a shaft? I thought perhaps the square was an opening on the deck rather than a shaft. Maybe it is a shaft that stops at the outside deck level. What do you think?

Of course we can't assume that Borodino had it from a plan of Orel. We can't assume that Orel had it either. all we can say is that the plan "indicates" something until we can have some supporting evidence. Kronma makes this same point in his post Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2007 7:21 am
I think, what yes.
At least, so it is written on the drawing and to specifications.

There appear to be ammunition hoists in Orel at the same place in this photo.


http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... ohoist.jpg

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... tlined.jpg

It is difficult to tell if there are two shafts at the conning level or just one. There is only one at the nav. bridge. But this is after the battle.


Which brings me appropriately onto my next topic, I have to do some revision I think... I think now that Borodino definitely had her forward booms permanently fixed at an angle, like Suvorov and Alex III. Therefore, there was only one rope needed to raise and lower the boats.

I think this because

1 all the photos of Borodino have the forward booms set at an angle, never horizontal (Orel's booms are horizontal in most photos I have seen). They seem to be at the same angle too, I think.

2 In the photo of her fitting out, her booms are on a rest. They are wooden and must be only temporary.

Sorry for starting a false thread, I was making assumptions.

But it is true of Orel. Interestingly I think I may have spotted two pulleys instead of one at the "mast" or "frame" top. So many little differences!!! But I am only guessing because it is a low resolution photograph. Anyway, information about Orel should really be saved for when we start discussing her I think.

I am sure there will be a winch somewhere at the forward end, probably somewhere right under our noses!!

As for winches to swing the boats in board and ouboard, there are some winches marked on Orel's builder's drawings. I have outlined them in red. Also there is a winch that is not marked, I marked its position in red as well. There are probably more. Possibly some of these were used?


http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... hlined.jpg

Thanks
John
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

cerberusjf wrote:I was wondering if the manual hoist/escape ladder were not in a shaft? I thought perhaps the square was an opening on the deck rather than a shaft. Maybe it is a shaft that stops at the outside deck level. What do you think?
You might be right John. In all the Russian warships of the period the ammunition hoists were equipped with doors which appear to be too big for the sole purpose of ammunition handling. So if those shafts were also used for emergency escapes those doors make sense all of a sudden. But arrangement ofammunition handling shafts for Borodino isn't exactly clear: in the photo of Borodino's bridge have door at the conning tower platform level but no vivible means of access at the navigation platform level. I would not have expected a door there (there is no need to bring the escaping sailors this high up) but I would like to see some sort of opening.... There is also nothing projecting above the compass platform but, again, it makes sense since there were no guns on this platform. BUT if you look at the photo of Borodino's rear bridge there appear to be 3 shafts there! One to the port, one (assumed and invisible in the photo) to the starboard and one in the middle with a gap where the door would have been fitted.
cerberusjf wrote:I think now that Borodino definitely had her forward booms permanently fixed at an angle, like Suvorov and Alex III. Therefore, there was only one rope needed to raise and lower the boats.
Possibly, but if you look at the photo of Aleks.III during trials (painted white) you will notice that her booms are down. So maybe there is similar photo of Borodino or Suvorov which we haven't managed to get hold of yet? I wish Tsushima's site was back online. He did have quite a few photos of Borodino which might have been quite usefull right now...
cerberusjf wrote: There appear to be ammunition hoists in Orel at the same place in this photo.
It is difficult to tell if there are two shafts at the conning level or just one. There is only one at the nav. bridge. But this is after the battle.
I am not arguing that there weren't. I am just not sure if there was one like in Borodino or two like in original drawings :big_grin:
cerberusjf wrote: As for winches to swing the boats in board and ouboard, there are some winches marked on Orel's builder's drawings. I have outlined them in red. Also there is a winch that is not marked, I marked its position in red as well.
All 4 of those winches are marked as http://i7.tinypic.com/6lxnmvb.jpg which means "Winches for...." but I can't work out the 3rd and the 4th word. Maybe Kronma can help?
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Yes you are absolutely right about Alexander. I have a photo of her painted black with her forward starboard boom definitely down and the port one out of its support. You can see the support clearly against the base of the forward funnel. This suggests that they were not fixed at all. Well spotted Darius!! :big_grin:

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... r3-04b.jpg


I had based this comment on the side plan of Alexander, which I thought showed them fixed.. I'd better withdraw the statement completely and restrict it to saying that I have not seen a machanism or any evidence yet for raising and lowering the forward boom on Borodino. :-)
Post Reply

Return to “Battleships”