Calling all Borodino (Бородино) class (Tsushima 1905) fans

Battleships and Battlecruisers of all nations and eras.
BB and BC.

Moderators: BB62vet, MartinJQuinn, Timmy C, Gernot, Olaf Held, Dan K, HMAS, ModelMonkey

Post Reply
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

DariusP wrote:All 4 of those winches are marked as "Winches for...." but I can't work out the 3rd and the 4th word. Maybe Kronma can help?
I do not know, what books about BORODINO-type ships are in English... It would be easier to me to write on technical details. :smallsmile:
In this case - Temperlay's booms meant.
It were special devices for loading coal in the sea.
I shall try to pick up corresponding documents...
OFF-TOP:
Englishmen, be silent! :sorry:
I looked football...
I laughed and cried... :cry_3: :cry_3:
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Well Kronma, since I am not an Englishman I have actually supported Russia in this match so I know how you feel. But I think that all is not lost and England will still have harder time to get through than Russia.

Thank you for the translation. I do read and write in Russian but some of those technical terms are just impossible for me to understand. So I didn't know what Темперлей ment and could not work out just what was the 4th letter in the 3rd word. But now I know as well what Spencer Miller winch was doing on the Orel. It was a part of Temperley/Miller system of coaling at sea! Interestingly enough Borodino didn't have Spencer Miller winches installed.

As for books about Borodinos in English: the only one that I recall was V. Arbuzov's "Borodino Class Armored Ships". More of a brochure than a book and with very basic informations only.
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

cerberusjf wrote: I was wondering if the manual hoist/escape ladder were not in a shaft? I thought perhaps the square was an opening on the deck rather than a shaft. Maybe it is a shaft that stops at the outside deck level. What do you think?
John, it is fine idea! :smallsmile:
Really, it were not shafts of manual submission, but HATCHES!
Therefore, them it is not visible in photos.

Image
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

cerberusjf wrote:But I see a small problem.
Where does the rope go after "3"? It has to go forward and it has to go to a winch at some point. The only thing I can see would be the capstan. Would the use the capstan to raise the boats? The rope could go under the 6" turret. But do you know if it was like that? Or was there another winch that we can't see?
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... lined3.jpg
It seems to me, that it could look here so:

Image

It's only my assumption...
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

cerberusjf wrote:As for winches to swing the boats in board and ouboard, there are some winches marked on Orel's builder's drawings. I have outlined them in red. Also there is a winch that is not marked, I marked its position in red as well. There are probably more. Possibly some of these were used?
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... hlined.jpg
Winch № 27 was precisely used for rise of boats.
Image
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Thanks kronma,

For the ammunition hoist I understand something like this.

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... filled.jpg

This is the only photo I have of winch "28". I wold like to find out more about this system of coaling at sea. There seems to be another winch here too, I have marked it "?" Do you know anything about it?

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... elined.jpg

On the plans from navarin, sheet 5, it is labelled
"ТРОСОВОЯ ВЬЮШКО О РУЧНОИ #Е#ЕДКОИ"
I cannot make out the letters marked "#" and I may have got something wrong.

Thanks
John
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

cerberusjf wrote:There seems to be another winch here too, I have marked it "?" Do you know anything about it?
On the plans from navarin, sheet 5, it is labelled
"ТРОСОВОЯ ВЬЮШКО О РУЧНОИ #Е#ЕДКОИ"
I cannot make out the letters marked "#" and I may have got something wrong.
The detail marked as "?" is reel with hand-winch ("ТРОСОВАЯ ВЬЮШКА С РУЧНОЙ ЛЕБЁДКОЙ").

Image
cerberusjf wrote:This is the only photo I have of winch "28". I wold like to find out more about this system of coaling at sea.
I am not assured, that winch"28" on a photo, is the same winch as it is drawn on original drawings. :eyebrows:
It seems to me, on a photo - electric winch, and on drawings - steam winch.
Unfortunately, more detailed information at me is not present.
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Kronma, once again terrific drawings! Thank you! Are both of those drawings of Borodino? If so, I am wondering about the bottom drawing..... Fragment of Conning Tower base that we can see looks nothing like the base in drawings of Orel. Could it have been different in both ships or is it just a drawing of an early (1901) version which was changed later?
KRONMA wrote: Winch № 27 was precisely used for rise of boats
We don't have problem with that Kronma. Trouble is that we can't find similar winches which could be connected with forward booms!

John please nothe that the drawing http://radikal.ru/F/i036.radikal.ru/071 ... 2.jpg.html It shows that Charthouse was indeed of the same size as Captain's Cabin and that this cabin did have rounded corners!

Your "?" reel, as Kronma already have said, is labelled as "Rope (cable) reel with hand winch" and is not associated with any particular function. I also agree with Kronma that what you call "winch 28" in the photo of damaged Orel isn't really that. It not only doesn't look similar but there also is a lot of debris in the area and, for all we know, this winch could have fallen from the upper level.

If you are interested in Temperley/Miller system of coaling at sea read this artice: http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/ ... oaling.htm but notice that Borodino didn't have Spencer Miller winches installed and from the plan view I can't tell if she had winches for Temperley system either. It could be that, while Miller part of the system dealt with "over the stern" coalling, the Temperley part might have dealt with side by side coaliing but it needs more research.

Very interesting journal of a Russian offices dealing with Battle of the Yellow Sea: http://www.wtj.com/archives/semenov/sem ... ta_02x.htm I haven't checked it for accuracy but a great read!
Last edited by DariusP on Sun Nov 18, 2007 1:53 pm, edited 3 times in total.
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Double post sorry!
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

DariusP wrote:John please nothe that the drawing http://radikal.ru/F/i036.radikal.ru/071 ... 2.jpg.html It shows that Charthouse was indeed of the same size as Captain's Cabin and that this cabin did have rounded corners!
Yes they do indeed. They also match the navarin plans well. It's just that, if you pardon the pun, I can't square it with the photographs. The corners look sharp in kronma's photographs :smallsmile: The difference is not much anyway, it's not like the curves in the lower part of the aft superstructure.

As you know I think they were built to fill the gaps between the "masts" and I think kronma's photos have shown that. So in practice they would be the same width. As the masts had sharp corners on the navigation platform level (presumably on the chart room level as well) only the forward corners of the cabins are really of concern as they are the only ones showing, if my belief is correct. As other plans show sharp corners, I don't think we can assume that this plan is definitive. For me the jury is still out, but with a majority in favour of square.


http://radikal.ru/F/i050.radikal.ru/071 ... 4.jpg.html


http://radikal.ru/F/i012.radikal.ru/071 ... 6.jpg.html
DariusP wrote: Your "?" reel, as Kronma already have said, is labelled as "Rope (cable) reel with hand winch" and is not associated with any particular function. I also agree with Kronma that what you call "winch 28" in the photo of damaged Orel isn't really that. It not only doesn't look similar but there also is a lot of debris in the area and, for all we know, this winch could have fallen from the upper level
Or it could be another winch that's not included in the plans. It is too far forward to be in the same position as "28" I now realise. :oops:
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Have a look at this photo John: http://i5.tinypic.com/6tnxc34.jpg It clearly shows that there was a rounded corner in the cabin on the aft bridge (01) but I agree that cabins on the main bridge might have been different.
Notice also 02 - a vent (shown nicely in naravin.ru drawings) where Orel did have Spencer Miller winch.
cerberusjf

Post by cerberusjf »

Yes I know, that's why I say the aft cabin was rounded :-). If the forward cabins are rounded, they don't appear to be as clearly rounded as the aft ones. The problem is that curves show up better when in close up and painted black, like the aft ones in the photos I have. I haven't seen an equivalent for the forward ones. kronma's bottom-left photo, sa good as it is, is from a distance.

I can just make out the winch in the photo on p21 of Arbuzov's book, I thought I had a jpeg of it, but no. It is also on the builder's plans of course.

There are some nice details in the 2006 plans from navarin. There's also another winch on sheet 3, but it's another hand winch.
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

cerberusjf wrote:Yes I know, that's why I say the aft cabin was rounded :-).
Sorry John missed that bit :oops:
User avatar
Tom L.
Posts: 173
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 7:59 pm
Location: Hamilton, Ohio

Post by Tom L. »

The cable reel with hand-winch looks almost exactly like one in an on-deck photo of Rurik from 1895; a mass produced type, and fitted to most Russian ships of the time?
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Wouldn't suprise me one little bit if it was so Tom. Can you post this photo? :thumbs_up_1:
Last edited by DariusP on Sun Nov 18, 2007 5:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

DariusP wrote:Are both of those drawings of Borodino?
Yes.
DariusP wrote:...(shown nicely in naravin.ru drawings)...
cerberusjf wrote:There are some nice details in the 2006 plans from navarin.
Forgive, you speak about what plans (drawings)?
Casually, not about these? :smallsmile:

Image

Concerns to them it is necessary very cautiously - in them a lot of imagination.
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

DariusP wrote:It shows that Charthouse was indeed of the same size as Captain's Cabin and that this cabin did have rounded corners!
cerberusjf wrote:For me the jury is still out, but with a majority in favour of square.
Surprisingly, but both of you are right in this question! :smallsmile:
It is a fragment of original BORODINO's drawing (11 November 1901).

Image
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

KRONMA wrote:Concerns to them it is necessary very cautiously - in them a lot of imagination.
We noticed that Kronma :big_grin: That is why we are talking about individual details from those plans and not plans as a whole
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Post by KRONMA »

DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Post by DariusP »

Thanks for the photos Kronma! Here is another view of the winch from another angle (also from Riurik): http://i9.tinypic.com/6lu9boo.jpg
Now, have you any idea about positions of doors and windows in Captain's Cabin and Chartchouse? I am still not sure if there was 1 or 2 windows per side ( I know there were 2 at the back) and if, because of the stairs, the doors were in the same position?
Post Reply

Return to “Battleships”