Kronma, once again terrific drawings! Thank you! Are both of those drawings of Borodino? If so, I am wondering about the bottom drawing..... Fragment of Conning Tower base that we can see looks nothing like the base in drawings of Orel. Could it have been different in both ships or is it just a drawing of an early (1901) version which was changed later?
KRONMA wrote:
Winch № 27 was precisely used for rise of boats
We don't have problem with that Kronma. Trouble is that we can't find similar winches which could be connected with forward booms!
John please nothe that the drawing
http://radikal.ru/F/i036.radikal.ru/071 ... 2.jpg.html It shows that Charthouse was indeed of the same size as Captain's Cabin and that this cabin did have rounded corners!
Your "?" reel, as Kronma already have said, is labelled as "Rope (cable) reel with hand winch" and is not associated with any particular function. I also agree with Kronma that what you call "winch 28" in the photo of damaged Orel isn't really that. It not only doesn't look similar but there also is a lot of debris in the area and, for all we know, this winch could have fallen from the upper level.
If you are interested in Temperley/Miller system of coaling at sea read this artice:
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/ ... oaling.htm but notice that Borodino didn't have Spencer Miller winches installed and from the plan view I can't tell if she had winches for Temperley system either. It could be that, while Miller part of the system dealt with "over the stern" coalling, the Temperley part might have dealt with side by side coaliing but it needs more research.
Very interesting journal of a Russian offices dealing with Battle of the Yellow Sea:
http://www.wtj.com/archives/semenov/sem ... ta_02x.htm I haven't checked it for accuracy but a great read!