And still no mention of these masts in the plans.
Calling all Borodino (Бородино) class (Tsushima 1905) fans
Moderators: BB62vet, MartinJQuinn, Timmy C, Gernot, Olaf Held, Dan K, HMAS, ModelMonkey
-
cerberusjf
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
Well, I am not ready to claim victory yet since I would really like to see clear photographic confimation of this. We know only too well that original drawings aren't always correct. Look, for example, at drawings of Borodino Conning Tower platform provided by Kronma: we know that there wasn't any hummock storage in places shown there.
And yes, you are right about lack of any references to masts (except, possibly, in plan view drawings). Puzzling......
And yes, you are right about lack of any references to masts (except, possibly, in plan view drawings). Puzzling......
- Tom L.
- Posts: 173
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 7:59 pm
- Location: Hamilton, Ohio
That's the one I had in mind, Darius; for some reason it refuses to upload onto Imageshack.DariusP wrote:Thanks for the photos Kronma! Here is another view of the winch from another angle (also from Riurik): http://i9.tinypic.com/6lu9boo.jpg
-
cerberusjf
DariusP wrote: If you are interested in Temperley/Miller system of coaling at sea read this artice: http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/ ... oaling.htm but notice that Borodino didn't have Spencer Miller winches installed and from the plan view I can't tell if she had winches for Temperley system either. It could be that, while Miller part of the system dealt with "over the stern" coalling, the Temperley part might have dealt with side by side coaliing but it needs more research.
Very interesting journal of a Russian offices dealing with Battle of the Yellow Sea: http://www.wtj.com/archives/semenov/sem ... ta_02x.htm I haven't checked it for accuracy but a great read!
Thanks for these Darius, I was just too tires to read these properly last night. Tonight hopefully
-
cerberusjf
Hi
I was looking at this photograph, which is labelled as Alexander III.
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... _iii_2.jpg
I noticed two things. There is a winch very similar to the one I mislabelled "28 " on the Orel photograph.
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... elined.jpg
Also there is a boat next to the turret. It is I think the aft turret. If I am correct, Alexander III did not have a boat here. Only Borodino and Orel did. As the skylights are parallel to the centre line of the ship, it would be Orel. This winch is shown in the exact position on the Orel drawings.
Unfortunately it is not numbered.
photo orelsternwinchlined
Also is it this winch that can be seen in this photo of Alexander III?
I_Aleksandr3-04bwinchlined.JPG
I was looking at this photograph, which is labelled as Alexander III.
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... _iii_2.jpg
I noticed two things. There is a winch very similar to the one I mislabelled "28 " on the Orel photograph.
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... elined.jpg
Also there is a boat next to the turret. It is I think the aft turret. If I am correct, Alexander III did not have a boat here. Only Borodino and Orel did. As the skylights are parallel to the centre line of the ship, it would be Orel. This winch is shown in the exact position on the Orel drawings.
Unfortunately it is not numbered.
photo orelsternwinchlined
Also is it this winch that can be seen in this photo of Alexander III?
I_Aleksandr3-04bwinchlined.JPG
Last edited by cerberusjf on Mon Feb 18, 2008 5:50 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
I agree that the first photo could have been mislabelled and that it is Orel rather than Aleks.III I also agree that the winch you pointed to looks identical. Interestingly enough, looking at drawings of Orel, I haven't noticed them installed anywhere else but aft. So the winch in the photo of battle damaged Orel must have been either carried there or blown at an amazing distance by an explosion of some kind!
- KRONMA
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
- Location: Moscow, Russia
Yes, it is same winch on Alexander III.cerberusjf wrote: Also is it this winch that can be seen in this photo of Alexander III?
But it is established not in parallel to the centre line of the ship.
It's ALEXANDER III.

Last edited by KRONMA on Fri Nov 23, 2007 6:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
cerberusjf
The photo of Orel matches the plan for one side. I suppose it is impossible to say for sure that there was one on the other side unless we can :-DariusP wrote:But according to the original drawings of Orel there were two winches of this type installed: one portside and one starboard isn't it correct?
1 find a photograph showing the other winch
or
2 find a specific reason why there would need to be one either side.
Does anyone know if Borodino had these winches?
Also I was wondering if people agreed that Borodino did not have recesses in her conning tower base? The photos from Kronma I think show that it looks a smooth curve, or at most a slight indent in the area of the captstan. The plan of Orel show a deep groove here, something that has been seen in other plans .

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... 027010.jpg
compare with the plan of Orel,
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... lined3.jpg
Also the railings on the secondary turrets of Borodino appear to be similar to Orel. But there seems to be something going from one side to the other and joining two "rods" in the middle of the turret.
lined.
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... lined3.jpg
unlined.
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... ailing.jpg
A quick sketch.
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... glined.jpg
Does anyone know what is going on here?
Thanks
John
edited to correct spelling and correct link
Last edited by cerberusjf on Tue Feb 19, 2008 7:21 am, edited 3 times in total.
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
I agree with the first point but:cerberusjf wrote:The photo of Orel matches the plan for one side. I suppose it is impossible to say for sure that there was one on the other side unless we can :-
1 find a photograph showing the other winch
or
2 find a specific reason why there would need to be one either side.
1- since drawing of Orel's plan view show two winches (port and starboard),
2- the photo in question shows winch as offset to the starboard,
3- all the starboard's winches you care to name seems to have their equivalent on the portside.
Taking all this into account I would argue the opposite to your second point: find a specific reason why, in this case, a single offset winch will do!
That's perceptions for you Johncerberusjf wrote:Also I was wondering if people agreed that Borodino did not have recesses in her conning tower base? The photos from Kronma I think show that it looks a smooth curve, or at most a slight indent in the area of the captstan. The plan of Orel show a deep groove here, something that has been seen in other plans (eg Malkov)
Orel secondary turrets raling: there are just too many ropes in this photo to be exactly sure of where every bit belongs to, where it begins and where it ends but I would have thought it very strange to have a separate roped-off area at the front of the turret with no means of access to it. What would be the point? If it wasn't ment to be accesible it wouldn't have railing and if it was, it would have an access to it don't you think?
-
cerberusjf
LOL!! I could add another reason for there being a port-side winch. The winch could only operate on the starboard side of Orel from that position, so a matching partner on the port side is highly likely. But I think we need more evidence to be absolutely sure there was one. I think it is a good assumption, but I also think we should remember that it is an assumptionDariusP wrote:
1- since drawing of Orel's plan view show two winches (port and starboard),
2- the photo in question shows winch as offset to the starboard,
3- all the starboard's winches you care to name seems to have their equivalent on the portside.
Taking all this into account I would argue the opposite to your second point: find a specific reason why, in this case, a single offset winch will do!
-
cerberusjf
I forgot to say thank you very much for this photo Kronma, my jaw dropped when I saw it!!KRONMA wrote:Yes, it is same winch on Alexander III.cerberusjf wrote: Also is it this winch that can be seen in this photo of Alexander III?
But it is established not in parallel to the centre line of the ship.![]()
It's ALEXANDER III.
http://radikal.ru/F/i005.radikal.ru/071 ... f.jpg.html][img]http://i005.radikal.ru/0711/1a/d47fc06e3f8ft.jpg
It is fantastic to see something close up. We can see clearly that it is the same type of winch. I like it when there seems to be a pattern and we can see the small differences too.
There are times when people look at a photo and never be able to know the answer for sure. I'm very glad it's not the case on this occasion.
Best wishes
John
-
Roman1
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
Your question is supprisingly difficult to answer because there was no single scheme used. I have seen photo of white painted Russian ships with white painted platform railing and unpainted deck railings as well as ships with unpainted platform and deck railings. There are photos of Peresviet during construction with stanchions of deck railing painted white... My guess would be that, when freshly painted, all railing (except ropes) was white but, with use, it got dirty and grubby very fast and was the first thing to be stripped of whatever reminded of the white paint...
-
cerberusjf
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... l1crop.jpg
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... 028005.jpg
By �white ship� do you mean �I Alexander� on her trials and �Borodino� and �Orel� under construction?
I am not sure at all what colour the railings would be but, as Darius says, probably white. As a potential complication, I wonder if the turret tops for �I Alexander� and in this crop of a photo of �Orel� were painted a dark colour, possibly black? The railings look darker on the turret tops too, perhaps they were painted black to match the tops or were just weathered? They seem to stand out more against the white hull or superstructure when compared to other railings.
The photo of �Orel� shows a couple of interesting details. I think it shows
1 a door in the middle of the starboard side of the captain�s cabin
2 the window arrangement for the starboard side and the starboard end of the forward side of the captain�s cabin
3 possibly a door in the middle of the starboard side of the chartroom
4 the arrangement of deck supports for the compass/searchlight platform and navigation bridge, quite different from Borodino.
On a more controversial note I think it also shows
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... oplied.jpg
5 the parts that I have been calling �boat masts� or �frame�to the side of the Captain�s cabin earlier in this thread. It looks to me to be also outside the chartroom, but a bit wider on this level. Why this would be I have no idea. They also look closed in at the front, so they have a [_] section or a complete box section, I think so anyway. I have outlined them in blue.
6 The red arrow shows part of the reason why I think the conning tower base �recess� curves are flatter than the �Orel� builders plans. If the plans were correct, I would expect the top of the base to be below the tip of the red arrow from this angle.
There are more reasons why I think the conning tower base has flatter recesses than the plans and still have doubts about the arrangement on Borodino. But that's another story for another time I think
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... 028005.jpg
By �white ship� do you mean �I Alexander� on her trials and �Borodino� and �Orel� under construction?
I am not sure at all what colour the railings would be but, as Darius says, probably white. As a potential complication, I wonder if the turret tops for �I Alexander� and in this crop of a photo of �Orel� were painted a dark colour, possibly black? The railings look darker on the turret tops too, perhaps they were painted black to match the tops or were just weathered? They seem to stand out more against the white hull or superstructure when compared to other railings.
The photo of �Orel� shows a couple of interesting details. I think it shows
1 a door in the middle of the starboard side of the captain�s cabin
2 the window arrangement for the starboard side and the starboard end of the forward side of the captain�s cabin
3 possibly a door in the middle of the starboard side of the chartroom
4 the arrangement of deck supports for the compass/searchlight platform and navigation bridge, quite different from Borodino.
On a more controversial note I think it also shows
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... oplied.jpg
5 the parts that I have been calling �boat masts� or �frame�to the side of the Captain�s cabin earlier in this thread. It looks to me to be also outside the chartroom, but a bit wider on this level. Why this would be I have no idea. They also look closed in at the front, so they have a [_] section or a complete box section, I think so anyway. I have outlined them in blue.
6 The red arrow shows part of the reason why I think the conning tower base �recess� curves are flatter than the �Orel� builders plans. If the plans were correct, I would expect the top of the base to be below the tip of the red arrow from this angle.
There are more reasons why I think the conning tower base has flatter recesses than the plans and still have doubts about the arrangement on Borodino. But that's another story for another time I think
Last edited by cerberusjf on Tue Feb 19, 2008 7:23 am, edited 2 times in total.
-
cerberusjf
Derricks
I think I figured out how they raised and lowered the derricks. I think they could not be raised independantly of the hook but were raised by the hook (or something that would stop the rope from going through the pulley). A rope of fixed length (which was already attached to the far end of the derrick)was attached to the mast end and held the derrick up. This freed the hook to raise and lower the boats. The Derricks could be lowered using the reverse of this process.
I could never understand why on the plans and the St Petersburg model the rope holding the derrick up was fixed at both ends when the derricks could be raised or lowered. But if one of the ends can be unattached then it makes sense. It also explaines why the derricks always seem to be at the same angle when raised. And it explaines why there is only one wheel in the pulley, because they only needed one rope to raise and lower both the derrick and the hook.
Now it makes sense!! I think !!!
A rather crude drawing
see below
I could never understand why on the plans and the St Petersburg model the rope holding the derrick up was fixed at both ends when the derricks could be raised or lowered. But if one of the ends can be unattached then it makes sense. It also explaines why the derricks always seem to be at the same angle when raised. And it explaines why there is only one wheel in the pulley, because they only needed one rope to raise and lower both the derrick and the hook.
Now it makes sense!! I think !!!
A rather crude drawing
see below
Last edited by cerberusjf on Mon Feb 18, 2008 6:10 pm, edited 2 times in total.
- Tom L.
- Posts: 173
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 7:59 pm
- Location: Hamilton, Ohio
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
What gets me is, why were the aft derricks on Imperator Aleksandr III stowed at a downward sloping angle, when the other ships stowed theirs horizontal?
- KRONMA
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
- Location: Moscow, Russia
Re: Derricks
cerberusjf, I believe, that you are right!cerberusjf wrote:I think I figured out how they raised and lowered the derricks....Now it makes sense!! I think !!!A rather crude drawing...
However, I wish to add, that this scheme of raised and lowered the derricks, needs to be considered SEPARATELY for each ship of a BORODINO-type.
Probably, by each ship there were small differences.
I believe, because it did not have a special structure, that fixed the derricks horizontally in the lowed position.Tom L. wrote:... why were the aft derricks on Imperator Aleksandr III stowed at a downward sloping angle...
