Calling all Borodino (Бородино) class (Tsushima 1905) fans

Battleships and Battlecruisers of all nations and eras.
BB and BC.

Moderators: BB62vet, MartinJQuinn, Timmy C, Gernot, Olaf Held, Dan K, HMAS, ModelMonkey

Post Reply
cerberusjf

Re: Derricks

Post by cerberusjf »

KRONMA wrote: I believe, that you are right! :smallsmile:
However, I wish to add, that this scheme of raised and lowered the derricks, needs to be considered SEPARATELY for each ship of a BORODINO-type.
Probably, by each ship there were small differences.
Thanks for the nice photos again kronma, it was this photo of Slava that gave me the idea, it shows the derricks in both lowered and raised positions. You can see the rope that I drew in green lying along the top of the lowered derrick. I drew it hanging under the derreck in my sketch to try to make it clearer what I meant. I am not sure if this is news to anyone, I hadn't really thought about it until now. :-)

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... 031006.jpg

Yes I agree there are small differences between the ships and should be considered separately in detail. To begin with, where the ropes that holds the derricks up are attached.

On Borodino and Orel they are attached to the pulleys (blocks) both on the forward and aft derrick.

On Suvorov it looks as if the forward derricks attached to the pulleys but I don't have a single photo showing the aft derricks raised. It looks like the plans show the aft derricks attached to the pulleys.

In I Alexander they are attached to - what appears to be for argument's sake - the "frame" or "mast" top on the forward end. It's difficult to see for definite as the photo is at the wrong angle, but it is definitely above the pulley and appears from that angle to be going in the same direction as the rope for the hook. The aft end is unclear for the same reasons as Suvorov, but the plans show them attached to the mast, above the pulley. You can see in the photo of I Alexander that the loose end of the rope was raised using a block and tackle.

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... _III22.jpg

There seems to be differences to where the aft derricks attach to the mast at the bottom.
I Alexander seems to be the highest, almost level with the top of the searchlight,
Suvorov's is lower, near the height of the railings
Orel and Borodino the lowest, so that the derrick rests almost at searchlight platform level.

Why does I Alexander have the derricks at an angle? I have't got a clue. As kronma says, it could be that there was no rest for them to go into. Or maybe it was to help lower the centre of gravity by keeping the derricks stowed as low as possible or maybe to make them easier to secure and more secure as well?
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

I am going to have a go on one of the ship�s derricks, Borodino�s aft derrick.

In case things are at different positions on different ships, I thought I would try to find out a common reference point. I am not sure if it a good choice, but I chose the height of the mainmast from the searchlight deck to the mast cap.

This is the first estimate of the height up the mast and only done on two photos. The two figures correspond to the two photos- outside brackets photo 1, inside brackets photo 2

1 the position if the pulley. I guess it�s midpoint to be about 59% (58%) up the mast.

2 the shape of the derrick rest is seen here, though it is difficult to work out its location exactly but it is about 48-50% of the distance from mainmast front edge to the aft edge of the aft funnel

3 the pivot is at deck level , searchlight deck level. level.

I haven�t calculated the angle the derrick is at yet s I don�t have enough info, but the postcard should give a good idea.

The platform (4) is about 46% (46%) up the mast from searchlight deck level.

The mast searchlight platform is about 50%(50%) up the mast

The fighting top is about 32% (31%) up the mast

The pole that sticks out aft.. (spanker? I�ve forgotten..) = 63% (63% ) upthe mast
lower yard = 64% (63% ) up the mast


Of course the errors are big, but even so these figures do not correspond with the plans by navarin (e.g the fighting top is 40% up the mast)

What I haven't done is work out the angle the derrick hung at, but it is clearly more horizontal than the photo of Slava above. Photo 2 is the nearst thing I have seen to a side on shot and gives the closest representation I can give. For anyone interested, the pulley midpoint on Slava is about 45% up the mast cf Borodino at 58-59% , assuming that the masts ARE the same height of course :-)


Has anyone else tried this?
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by KRONMA »

I think, that the masts were the same height. :smallsmile:
I hope, it will be interesting and usefull for you: :eyebrows:

Image
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

Thanks very much again! A picture says a thousand words and this one certainly says a lot :-) It looks like the masts were the same height on the plans, or near enough. But it seems the same height from the spar deck (the bottom red line I mean). :-)

The searchlight deck seems to be the same height in Borodino and Orel, but lower in Suvorov and Alexander 111. The deck below seems to be the same height on all these 4 ships, so the difference is the height is because the searchlight deck is not as high above the deck below.

Slava is an odd one, her searchlight deck is the same height as Borodino/Orel but is the same height above the lower deck as Suvorov and Alexander 111. This is because the deck below is higher than the other four ships.

Thanks again, I don't know how long this would have taken me to find out from photographs, if ever!!!!


This has reminded me that I tried some rough working on the Borodino aft bridge cabins from photographs. Please let me emphasise ROUGH :-) . I did it a while ago. But because I made some very large assumptions, I was too embarrassed to go public with it. I may post what I did if I have a few drinks..
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by DariusP »

John, great detective work about booms arangements on Borodino class. And with so little to go on - first class! :thumbs_up_1: Have those drinks asap. You have warned us that you made "assumptions" and I am curious how "large" they were :big_grin:

Talking about Borodin's aft booms... I wonder about arrangement of booms support. Kronma's drawings show it hanging up in he air with no connection to the deck below and Malkov's draws it as being mounted on the top of engine room vent. All in all, not clear at all!
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by KRONMA »

DariusP wrote: Kronma's drawings show it hanging up in he air with no connection to the deck below and Malkov's draws it as being mounted on the top of engine room vent.
It's not the detailed drawings, but general views. Because of that, the small details could be not drawn.
As I see in photos, the booms support have been established by all ships of BORODINO-type. :smallsmile:
Unfortunately, I did not study ships of BORODINO-type in detail enough to answer all questions.
I hope, that when in the autumn of 2008 the Naval Archive will open, I can answer questions precisely enough.
And now, I try to find answers only in those drawings which at me are... :(
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

DariusP wrote:You have warned us that you made "assumptions" and I am curious how "large" they were :big_grin:
Okay, well here goes... let me first say that different plans for borodino have all shown different arrangements for the deckhouses on the aft bridge of Borodino. Some show them all the same width (port to starboard) some all the same length (bow to stern) and some a completely different arrangement. So the problem was to try and find what parts seemed to be correct from all the plans.

I will start with the widths of the deckhouses.

This photograph is good for a variety of reasons. The verticals are true, the edges of the deckhouses are clear and it is almost square on (for the port side of the superstructure at least). The problem was trying to find a midpoint as the port 47mm gun hoist is obscured.

To establish a midpoint in the same plane as the lower deckhouse, in the end I decided to find the midpoint between the searchlight platform supports, which are roughly in the same plane. This is the horizontal orange line, marked �x�. From its midpoint I dropped a vertical line to the level of the lower cabin. We can now measure the width of the lower cabin . �l� is � the width = 132 units., the whole width is 264 units

Lower cabin = 264 units

To get the relative width of the upper cabin is a little more difficult as it is further away from the viewer. Although there is a window that we can take a midpoint from, the width would be smaller than it should because of perspective..

But it is almost square on, anything to the left disappears to the right and everything to the right of it disappears to the left.

So I just dropped a vertical from the upper cabin edge and measured its width from the lower deckhouse midpoint. I made the assumption that it was and any error would be too small to make much of a difference. It would be more accurate than trying to get a width from a different plane.

�u� is � upper cabin width = 108 units, the whole width = 216 units
Upper cabin = 216 units

Clearly narrower than the lower abin. In fact 0.82 of the width.

To give us another check, I decided to measure the width of the 47mm hoist, �h� =43 units, very nearly 1/5th the width of the upper cabin and 1/6th the lower cabin.

Another check was the width of the dek between, I get it to be 2* 201=402 units.

All this perfectly matches the widths form Darius� builders plan and does not match the others. So for deckhouse widths, Darius� plan is the winner :-)

Although there are large errors here and I have made assumptions, it is clear that the upper deck house is narrower than the lower one, and by the correct amount on Darius� drawing


It is late now so I�ll continue tomorrow.
In fact I will redo this by finding the vanishing point. That way I can see better how much the upper cabin width needs to be adjusted
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by DariusP »

I hope you didn't take my post as being critical Kronma. That was the last thing on my mind!
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

Well I had another go at doing this, finding the vanishing point was harder than I thought, I ended up with a compromise ( a gues in other words. But I did find out that my mid line was to the left a little and the port hoist is visible, it just looks different in this photo. The yellow line is a projection along the deck edge, the only good projection line I can get. I tried a few different things but none of them worked. I saw that the overhang supports were pointing directly, or very nearly, at the camera. This gave me two possible verticals to use, the real one must be around here. I projected these lines in pale blue. I assumed the stanchion on the overhang was in the middleprojected down to the bottom edge of the deck in dark blue, and projected through the midpoint at the top of the lower cabin in yellow. This gave a very rough approximation but limited the options to the left of the right-most pale blue line. Otherwise the centre of the cabin would be too far to starboard.

I chose the left pale blue line and projected a line in green, through the top left corner of the upper cabin and to the orange line. This is the best estimate I can get on the correct plane for the lower deckhouse. Then I took red line vertically down to the lower deckhouse..

This goves a revised widths as

Upper cabin approx =114 units*2 = 228 units
Lower cabin = 135 units*2 = 270 units
deck width = 205*2= 410 units

giving a ratio

upper cabin : lower cabin : deck of

5:5.92:8.99

as near as I think I could expect to Darius' plans ratio of

5:6:9

So I think the widths of the plans are correct.
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

Now for the cabin lengths,

from Darius/Baumann plans

A length fore cabin = 104 units = 48.2% of total A+B+C (78.1% of A+B)
B length of stairs = 29 units = 13.4% total
C length of aft cabin = 83 units = 38.4% total

length total = 216 units = 100%


from photo Borodino 24.jpg
total length = 96 units maximum as any more would be too close to the port side aft window.

I measured

length fore cabin = 48 units = 50% (78.6% of A+B)
length of stair well= 13 units = 13.5%
length of aft cabin estimate= 35 units = 36.5%

Because
a) 99 units would be needed to fit the proportions on the plans, which is too long and
b) the ratio of A:A+B was correct,
I thought the plans could be wrong somewhere in the aft cabin.

But now I think it is probably due to the curved corners of the cabins giving a slightly misleading edge and to errors in measurement. So I think the plans are correct again for the cabin lengths..


The door on the aft cabin side is a bit of a stretch of the imagination, but it looks like there is a window there.


I warned you it was rough!!! :-)
Last edited by cerberusjf on Wed Jan 23, 2008 8:04 am, edited 2 times in total.
Peter Van Buren
Posts: 118
Joined: Fri Oct 26, 2007 11:04 am

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by Peter Van Buren »

For what it is worth, I painted my Borodino Tamiya Dark Gray, with Paynes Grey oil weathering. Here and there I airbrushed Tamiya Smoke for darker effect, Dark Grey lightened with a touch of White for hilights.
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

If you thought that was a stretch of the imagination, here comes the worst.. To establish the length of the lower deckhouse, I could only use the photo and plan (in url) below. And, at best, it would be only a range of possible lengths..

I assumed that.

1 the frames on the lower deck would be the same as the upper.
2 the frame visible at the top of the cabin was "78" as it appeared to be in the right spot.
3 that 5 to 6 of the frames beyond frame "78" were part of the cabin. I thought you could see the white ends as they went through the black wall of the cabin. I thought it that it was possible there were more, but there was not enough light in the photo to see.

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... nt=305.jpg
Last edited by cerberusjf on Wed Jan 23, 2008 2:53 pm, edited 1 time in total.
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

So I copied and pasted the frames from the lower deck to the upper and basically guessed where the walls looked like being. The aft wall looked like it was almost up against frame "78" so I drew it close to frame "78". Perhaps it shoud be next to it. The fore wall is at frame "74" which is very near the stairs. It couldnt go nearer the stairs, so I drew it as far aft as possible, up against frame "74". This is what seems to appear in Darius's plans.

But I can see from the plans Andrew posted that maybe I made a mistake. On his plans the fore wall is aft of frame "74". Maybe there are only 5 frames in the cabin and the fore wall is aft of frame "74". Maybe there are 6 frames in the lower deck house and frame "78" is not "78", or something else is happening :-( It is difficult to see in the photo if that 6th frame is part of the cabin or not.

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... mistak.jpg

http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... istake.jpg

Can anyone recommend image software that I can draw and measure please? I can't do both with the same programs on the ones I use..
Last edited by cerberusjf on Thu Jan 31, 2008 9:27 am, edited 2 times in total.
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

Peter Van Buren wrote:For what it is worth, I painted my Borodino Tamiya Dark Gray, with Paynes Grey oil weathering. Here and there I airbrushed Tamiya Smoke for darker effect, Dark Grey lightened with a touch of White for hilights.
I just checked "what's new" and saw your ship, nice job! How did you glaze the pilot house windows????? And what colour did you use for the funnels?
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

Hi Darius,
I had a go at the boom support and have come up with something.

First I tried to establish its position in photographs.

Photo 1
Mast to funnel = 248
Mast � support = 122 = 49.19% of mast-funnel

Photo 2
Mast to funnel = 913
Mast � support = 447 = 48.96% of mast-funnel


On your plan dariusplan.jpg
Mast � funnel = 620
Mast � aft end of cradle = 303 = 48.87% of mast-funnel

This is where the aft end the boat cradles are i.e. the frame in front of frame 64. This is also the aft end of the entrance port

It is tempting to think that the support is attached to this cradle, as shown on the plans I have.

From the photos I have looked at the cradle seems to be just at the entrance port i.e 49% although I have not seen a clear photo yet. I have put a line pointing to where I think the boat cradle is on the photographs.
Last edited by cerberusjf on Mon Feb 18, 2008 6:12 pm, edited 2 times in total.
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

Here are crops of plans to compare with Darius' plan in the previous message and my old and generally inaccurate plan.
Last edited by cerberusjf on Mon Feb 18, 2008 6:13 pm, edited 3 times in total.
User avatar
KRONMA
Posts: 99
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
Location: Moscow, Russia

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by KRONMA »

At last, I could find a few free time! :smallsmile:
So, some words about the sizes of stern bridge's superstructures.
I used the drawings of 23 September, 1904. I hope, that it is last edition of drawings, the most correct.
I have painted different levels of the stern bridge in different colors that it was visible better.
I hope, this drawings will help you to define the size and an arrangement of superstructures precisely. :smallsmile:
Image

Image
DariusP
Posts: 941
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by DariusP »

Kronma you have posted those terrific drawings while I was writting my post. Thank you very much! Those drawings make things so much clearer and they also nicely support John's theories!
The amount of new informations about Borodinos which you have provided in relatively short time since you have joinded this thread is astonishing! Much appreciated.

Sorry for late reply John but it was a very busy week for me.

Let's first deal with aft booms support in Borodino: I think that Malkov hedges his bets here... In isometric view you posted it indeed looks like the support is build on the top of a catwalk (case A) but in the side view drawing of Borodino (Malkov again) it sure looks like the very same support rests on the top of engine room vent (case B).

I am inclined towards case A but I am wondering if catwalk was strong enough to carry the weight of the support (which was quite substantial) and booms! Case B is unlikely (IMO) because braces of the support would have to rest on (or go through) hatches of the machine room vent.

Now the problematic part: Malkov draws booms closer together than on the original yard drawing so the horizontal beam of the boom support would be of different lenght depending on whom you believe! Connected with this is a question of weight distribution: in Malkov's drawings vertical beams of boom support are close to the booms and so help to distribute the weight of those booms quite officiently. In the original yard drawing (if we assume boom support location and form similar to Malkov's) booms would be resting quite a distance away from vertical supports and so weight ditribution is much more problematic (at least,again, IMO). Here is a schematic (VERY) drawing of what I have in mind: Image
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

Thanks very much for your great plans Andrew- very clear and precise as always :-) I am still puzzled as to how long the admiral's cabin is. On the plan it goes all the way to frame 74 but on the elevation (side view) it stops short of frame 74... maybe there is not a definitive answer.. But I am glad that all those rough projections turned out to be in the right order at least.

I'm sorry if they are confusing to follow, I may go back and change the pictures and labelling to make it clearer. I did them late at night and in a hurry.
DariusP wrote: Let's first deal with aft booms support in Borodino: I think that Malkov hedges his bets here... In isometric view you posted it indeed looks like the support is build on the top of a catwalk (case A) but in the side view drawing of Borodino (Malkov again) it sure looks like the very same support rests on the top of engine room vent (case B).

I am inclined towards case A but I am wondering if catwalk was strong enough to carry the weight of the support (which was quite substantial) and booms! Case B is unlikely (IMO) because braces of the support would have to rest on (or go through) hatches of the machine room vent.

Now the problematic part: Malkov draws booms closer together than on the original yard drawing so the horizontal beam of the boom support would be of different lenght depending on whom you believe! Connected with this is a question of weight distribution: in Malkov's drawings vertical beams of boom support are close to the booms and so help to distribute the weight of those booms quite officiently. In the original yard drawing (if we assume boom support location and form similar to Malkov's) booms would be resting quite a distance away from vertical supports and so weight ditribution is much more problematic (at least,again, IMO). Here is a schematic (VERY) drawing of what I have in mind: Image
Thanks for your reply Darius, I know what you mean, it's been very busy with me too.

For the boom support I was trying to suggest another option to the ones you suggested. I doubt the catwalk would be able to support the boom rests+booms on their own without more support. Especially as it is in the middle of two beams for the boat "cradle". I think the rests were possibly on top of the aft beam of the boat "cradle", the one I think Malkov drew too far aft. I have circled the aft boat "cradle" beam and drawn my suggestion for its position in red. The boom supports are in blue. I think this is what is drawn in the plan that Andrew posted for the Borodino and what is on the plans I had in the message above. At least that is how I understand it :-)

I see what you mean that the buiders plans seem to sow the booms further apart. But it doesnt strike me as being a big difference. Also the booms rest in "U" shaped supports rather than on a horizontal beam.

I did a rough drawing on one of "Orel"'s builders drawing to help explain what I mean.
Last edited by cerberusjf on Mon Feb 18, 2008 5:23 pm, edited 1 time in total.
cerberusjf

Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans

Post by cerberusjf »

This is the old plan I have with the beam marked in red and support marked in blue to compare with the uncoloured one above.. It also shows the bracing that can be seen in the photograph. It is not clear if there is bracing aft of the support. It looks as if there is something there, but it is not clear.

Note - on both the plans, the fore bracing comes from the middle beam of the boat cradle at the side of the catwalk.
Last edited by cerberusjf on Mon Feb 18, 2008 6:05 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Post Reply

Return to “Battleships”