Calling all Borodino (Бородино) class (Tsushima 1905) fans
Moderators: BB62vet, MartinJQuinn, Timmy C, Gernot, Olaf Held, Dan K, HMAS, ModelMonkey
-
cerberusjf
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Hi Darius,
I think Kronma is correct for "Orel" , what he marked was the bakery. But the bakery does not fill the entire space, it forms a "ring" around the skylight.
The crop from the previous post only shows the part of the bakery aft of the skylight.
I filled the bakery area in green, but left the ovens un"green"ed to show where these were. Hope this picture explains it, it was done as fast as possible..I gotta go.
bye for now
John
I think Kronma is correct for "Orel" , what he marked was the bakery. But the bakery does not fill the entire space, it forms a "ring" around the skylight.
The crop from the previous post only shows the part of the bakery aft of the skylight.
I filled the bakery area in green, but left the ovens un"green"ed to show where these were. Hope this picture explains it, it was done as fast as possible..I gotta go.
bye for now
John
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Apologies Kronma you are right
I have checked Orel's drawings and bakery looks exactly how you marked it in your last post.
John, I have some concerns regarding Borodino's photo and drawing posted by you here: download/file.php?id=1022&mode=view and here download/file.php?id=1018&mode=view
This photo is interesting but also very confusing. It might (or might have not) been retouched but it was also not detailed enough and taken at such a stage in ship's construction that it's difficult to know what was already build and what was yet to be build as well what was temorary and what was permanent.
Now the questions:
1- in the drawing, skylight outlined by you in yellow, is in a different position on plan view drawing of Borodino (further aft) and I would need more reason than just this photo to relocate it to the position proposed by you.
2- what you call "Admiral's Cabin" (marked by you in red on the photo):
a- if you look at any photo of Borodinos during construction you will notice that cabins were build after platforms were installed and so I don't think that we can safely make any judgements about Admira's Cabin based on this photo. Besides IMO
b- your red markings locate this "cabin" too much forward by quite a distance. In fact it was much furter aft right in front of (looking from photo's perspective) rear turret and just behind the rear mast ( which isn't present in the photo).
I also have no idea what is the structure outline by you in green but, again, it could be something temporary or it could be something placed there only to be moved elsewhere later on.
The machinery vent seems to be the only structure shown relatively clearly and seems to be of "normal"
peaked roof contruction. But, since I am so suspicious about this photo, I am not using it as proof of anything 
John, I have some concerns regarding Borodino's photo and drawing posted by you here: download/file.php?id=1022&mode=view and here download/file.php?id=1018&mode=view
This photo is interesting but also very confusing. It might (or might have not) been retouched but it was also not detailed enough and taken at such a stage in ship's construction that it's difficult to know what was already build and what was yet to be build as well what was temorary and what was permanent.
Now the questions:
1- in the drawing, skylight outlined by you in yellow, is in a different position on plan view drawing of Borodino (further aft) and I would need more reason than just this photo to relocate it to the position proposed by you.
2- what you call "Admiral's Cabin" (marked by you in red on the photo):
a- if you look at any photo of Borodinos during construction you will notice that cabins were build after platforms were installed and so I don't think that we can safely make any judgements about Admira's Cabin based on this photo. Besides IMO
b- your red markings locate this "cabin" too much forward by quite a distance. In fact it was much furter aft right in front of (looking from photo's perspective) rear turret and just behind the rear mast ( which isn't present in the photo).
I also have no idea what is the structure outline by you in green but, again, it could be something temporary or it could be something placed there only to be moved elsewhere later on.
The machinery vent seems to be the only structure shown relatively clearly and seems to be of "normal"
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken
- KRONMA
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
- Location: Moscow, Russia
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Here a photo, where BORODINO's engine room vents is well visible.cerberusjf wrote: 1. the engine room vent closely matches the plan below. The top covers are not clearly visible, so I don't know what they were like. But I think there could be a faint scuttle visible (famous last words!!). In this photo, it is surrounded by a temporary wooden framework, outlined in orange.

It's not a bulkhead - it's the aft side of 6" turret.cerberusjf wrote: 2 The side wall of the Admiral's cabin (in red) extended forward of frame 74. The cabin itself may have stopped before (or at) frame 74, but the wall continued... I wish I had seen this photo before doing all those guesses ..
3 there was a bulkead (in green) . I am not sure exactly where it was, but I have placed it just forward of the aft 6" turret for now.
Yes, it is real so.cerberusjf wrote: 5 the aft beam of the boat cradle (in blue ) was definitely at the entry port.

- KRONMA
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
- Location: Moscow, Russia
-
cerberusjf
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Thanks once again Andrew, absouletly fantastic picture!!KRONMA wrote: Here a photo, where BORODINO's engine room vents is well visible.![]()
Yes I can see it nowKRONMA wrote:It's not a bulkhead - it's the aft side of 6" turret.cerberusjf wrote: 3 there was a bulkead (in green) . I am not sure exactly where it was, but I have placed it just forward of the aft 6" turret for now.![]()
Thanks for the confirmation!! I thought it was, but it is very good to get cast iron proof.KRONMA wrote:Yes, it is real so.cerberusjf wrote: 5 the aft beam of the boat cradle (in blue ) was definitely at the entry port.
I'm not really relocating it. I cut the skylight from that area in the plans because I couldn't see any signs of it in the photo. I pasted it to the area aft of the vent because there is a skylight there in the photo, but not in the plan. The area I cut the skylight from is an unknown for me. I do not mean that it is empty.DariusP wrote: 1- in the drawing, skylight outlined by you in yellow, is in a different position on plan view drawing of Borodino (further aft) and I would need more reason than just this photo to relocate it to the position proposed by you.
The skylight in Andrew's photo shows is in this area as well in my opinion. I am not saying it is the exact location, but is roughly the width of the skylight away from the vent. Possibly less, in fact. The skylight is about 1/3 the width of the vent, probably more. This part in italics, please ignore
The photo I posted has been retouched slightly. But the areas of the vent, skylight and Admiral's cabin are mostly untouched, only a little lining at the edges. I think it makes it valid -if poor quality- information.
Darius, my message says "The side wall of the Admiral's cabin (in red) extended forward of frame 74. The cabin itself may have stopped before (or at) frame 74, but the wall continued"DariusP wrote: b- your red markings locate this "cabin" too much forward by quite a distance. In fact it was much furter aft right in front of (looking from photo's perspective) rear turret and just behind the rear mast ( which isn't present in the photo).
My red markings for the Admiral's cabin don't actually change it's position. I only extended the side walls forward to where I thought it went to, by eye. It does go forward beyond the end of the Admiral's cabin, but only to frame aft of frame 72 to enclose the stairwell and to form a sort of"vestibule" to the Admiral's cabin.
It was too long, but not too far out for something done by eye. And is correct on the photo I think.
Here are some altered plans (minus the phantom bulkhead and corrected Admiral's cabin and skylight (or skylights?) to consider
Last edited by cerberusjf on Sun Feb 10, 2008 11:19 am, edited 2 times in total.
- Dave Stone
- Posts: 147
- Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2008 12:11 am
- Location: as far south as you can get before you run out of planet
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Hi Martin
I am building the exact same model myself although at a slow pace. The WEM PE set is what i went for also but have not touched much of it yet as I am still getting to grips with working with it. Doing other builds first to get more experience at it first. I used a very flat black for the hull above the water line and Tamiya dull red for the hull below the water line. No boot stripe as could not make one out in photos. I have the decks cleaned up and dry fitted and ready to put PE on before I primier and thats about as far as I have got
There are some realy very nice Borodino Class models in the Gallery here and thats what I am useing as a guid as much as I can
The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, but wiser people so full of doubts.
Bertrand Russell
Bertrand Russell
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
John, I am not being contrary for the sake of it. I have simply said that I was not prepared to draw conclusion from a single photo of a ship under construction. Now I have seen Kronma's photo of the vent too and I do indeed see a skylight right behind it. I don't know if it's the same skylight that plans show as being further aft, but there is definitively a skylight close behind the vent.
BTW as I see it, in the photo of Borodino under construction, this skylight seems to have a temporary cover. The finished skylight wouldn't be that high.
I am still not sure is I follow your arguments about the size of Admiral's Cabin but I am sticking to the shorter red rectangle (the one which doesn't incorporate the stairs) in the drawings above. This is also what Kronma suggested in one of his previous post. And, so far, I haven't seen any evidence compelling enough to change my mind.
Kronma: excellent photo of Borodino's machine room vent! Much appreciated! Now two questions:
1- do you know what is rectangle numbered 48 in plan view of Borodino ?
2- any ideas about shape of the left and right sides of platform drawn here http://radikal.ru/F/i001.radikal.ru/080 ... b.jpg.html in green? There were semicircular cutouts in the sides of this platform ( seen in photo here: download/file.php?id=566&mode=view ) but I have no idea of their exact size or location.
BTW as I see it, in the photo of Borodino under construction, this skylight seems to have a temporary cover. The finished skylight wouldn't be that high.
I am still not sure is I follow your arguments about the size of Admiral's Cabin but I am sticking to the shorter red rectangle (the one which doesn't incorporate the stairs) in the drawings above. This is also what Kronma suggested in one of his previous post. And, so far, I haven't seen any evidence compelling enough to change my mind.
Kronma: excellent photo of Borodino's machine room vent! Much appreciated! Now two questions:
1- do you know what is rectangle numbered 48 in plan view of Borodino ?
2- any ideas about shape of the left and right sides of platform drawn here http://radikal.ru/F/i001.radikal.ru/080 ... b.jpg.html in green? There were semicircular cutouts in the sides of this platform ( seen in photo here: download/file.php?id=566&mode=view ) but I have no idea of their exact size or location.
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken
- KRONMA
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
- Location: Moscow, Russia
-
cerberusjf
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Darius,
okay I concede that the skylight is in the place on the original plans, you were right!
I misjudged where the bottom of the skylight was. I have drawn where the true bottom probably lies.
I agree absolutely that we should have a critical eye on any posting, I just felt that this photograph had more value than you appeared to give it. I was probably giving it too much value and tried to get more out of it than was realistic.
I don't care that much personally whether my proposals are right or wrong, that's what we're here for I think. I try to be as correct as possible when posting and this one was a bit of a rush job. I was really posting it for the vent. The rest was just trying to get as much information out of the picture as possible.
okay I concede that the skylight is in the place on the original plans, you were right!
I misjudged where the bottom of the skylight was. I have drawn where the true bottom probably lies.
I agree absolutely that we should have a critical eye on any posting, I just felt that this photograph had more value than you appeared to give it. I was probably giving it too much value and tried to get more out of it than was realistic.
I don't care that much personally whether my proposals are right or wrong, that's what we're here for I think. I try to be as correct as possible when posting and this one was a bit of a rush job. I was really posting it for the vent. The rest was just trying to get as much information out of the picture as possible.
Last edited by cerberusjf on Sun Feb 10, 2008 11:14 am, edited 2 times in total.
-
cerberusjf
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
For the Admiral's cabin,
From what we found before
If the cabin starts at frame 78 and ends at frame 74,
A, distance from aft wall to forward edge of forward window = 187 pixels
B, distance from aft wall to fore wall = 246 pixels
A/B = 0.7601
But from the photo I posted I had 2 options depending on which vertical was chosen as the near end of the cabin wall.
The correct one gave an A/B of 0.531.
The other one gave an A/B of 0.401 which worked out as far too low had I done the calculations before I posted. But either way, both gave a A/B of much less than 0.76. So the cabin had to be longer than thought.
From Kronma�s photo (suffixed �p�)
Ap, distance from aft wall to forward edge of forward window = 48 pixels
Bp, distance from aft wall to fore wall = 84 pixels
Ap/Bp =0.571
If we want to find the length of Bp on the plans we need to do
A/(Ap/Bp) = 187/0.571=327pixels
This is the distance from frame 78 to frame aft of frame 72 circled in red (sorry it's not actually 73. At this level you get 3 frames for 2, so it gets confusing.)
What do you think?
From what we found before
If the cabin starts at frame 78 and ends at frame 74,
A, distance from aft wall to forward edge of forward window = 187 pixels
B, distance from aft wall to fore wall = 246 pixels
A/B = 0.7601
But from the photo I posted I had 2 options depending on which vertical was chosen as the near end of the cabin wall.
The correct one gave an A/B of 0.531.
The other one gave an A/B of 0.401 which worked out as far too low had I done the calculations before I posted. But either way, both gave a A/B of much less than 0.76. So the cabin had to be longer than thought.
From Kronma�s photo (suffixed �p�)
Ap, distance from aft wall to forward edge of forward window = 48 pixels
Bp, distance from aft wall to fore wall = 84 pixels
Ap/Bp =0.571
If we want to find the length of Bp on the plans we need to do
A/(Ap/Bp) = 187/0.571=327pixels
This is the distance from frame 78 to frame aft of frame 72 circled in red (sorry it's not actually 73. At this level you get 3 frames for 2, so it gets confusing.)
What do you think?
Last edited by cerberusjf on Sun Feb 10, 2008 3:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Kronma, thanks for the answer. Appreciated as usual
I also might not always agree with the results but I appreciate your habit of trying to squeeze every last ounce of information from a photo. If it wasn't for that, the possibility that Orel had a very unusual machine room vent might have never come to light!
Let me think a bit more about Admiral's Cabin. I will get back to you on that
Well John, that's why I am so glad to have you onboard in this thread! Between you and me, and with invaluable help from Kronma, we are getting some great results! Like you I also don't mind being wrong. I am not here for my ego but to find as many facts as we possibly cancerberusjf wrote:I just felt that this photograph had more value than you appeared to give it. I was probably giving it too much value and tried to get more out of it than was realistic.
I don't care that much personally whether my proposals are right or wrong, that's what we're here for I think. I try to be as correct as possible when posting and this one was a bit of a rush job. I was really posting it for the vent. The rest was just trying to get as much information out of the picture as possible.
I also might not always agree with the results but I appreciate your habit of trying to squeeze every last ounce of information from a photo. If it wasn't for that, the possibility that Orel had a very unusual machine room vent might have never come to light!
Let me think a bit more about Admiral's Cabin. I will get back to you on that
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Ok John, first you will have to explain to me once again ( SLOWLY
) why you are happy to accept that Admiral's Cabin sits conveniently between frames 78 and 74 and than go through complicated ( and, by your own admission, not very accurate) series of calculations to get its length? Since frames in Borodino were 4 feet apart, so the length of the cabin would be 16 feet or 4.9 meters. Now, did I miss something?
And now my attempt at taking measurements from photograph: I have done my drawing on a printout of this photo and using pencil, ruler and triangle but here is rough sketch of what I have done:

I have marked front and rear end of the side wall as well as front and rear end of the doorframe. Now, if the width of the door frame in this photo is "X" than (according to my calculations) the length of the whole wall is X times 7 (on my printout the door frame is 7mm wide and the whole wall is 49mm wide). I know that it isn't necesseryli so but to get anywhere I have to assume that all the measurements are foreshortened by the same amount in this view. Now I will have to find out how wide Borodino's doors were and I will have lenght of the cabin. I don't think that results will be very accurate, but it should give me sort of ballpark figure.
And now my attempt at taking measurements from photograph: I have done my drawing on a printout of this photo and using pencil, ruler and triangle but here is rough sketch of what I have done:

I have marked front and rear end of the side wall as well as front and rear end of the doorframe. Now, if the width of the door frame in this photo is "X" than (according to my calculations) the length of the whole wall is X times 7 (on my printout the door frame is 7mm wide and the whole wall is 49mm wide). I know that it isn't necesseryli so but to get anywhere I have to assume that all the measurements are foreshortened by the same amount in this view. Now I will have to find out how wide Borodino's doors were and I will have lenght of the cabin. I don't think that results will be very accurate, but it should give me sort of ballpark figure.
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken
- KRONMA
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
- Location: Moscow, Russia
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
As I know, the width of a door in radiotelegraph cabin was 2'-0".DariusP wrote:Now I will have to find out how wide Borodino's doors were...
I believe, that doors were standard.
I have closely looked at a photo still time.
I think, that I was mistaken and that John speaks correctly - the ?dmiral's cabin looked how it has drawn.
Besides it seems to me, I have found hatches (a green line), drawn on the drawing.
What will you tell?

- KRONMA
- Posts: 99
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 6:38 am
- Location: Moscow, Russia
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Unfortunately, I do not have the original drawing of these semicircular cutouts.DariusP wrote:Now two questions:
2- any ideas about shape of the left and right sides of platform drawn here http://radikal.ru/F/i001.radikal.ru/080 ... b.jpg.html in green? There were semicircular cutouts in the sides of this platform ( seen in photo here: download/file.php?id=566&mode=view ) but I have no idea of their exact size or location.
But I can assume, what for they have been made - when 6" turrets rotated, they touched the platform.
This problem have solved in two ways:
1 - have lifted the bridge above both did not do semicircular cutouts,
2 - have left the platform without changes, having made semicircular cutouts in the sides.

-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Thanks for coming up with great info again Kronma!
Well, if the door was 2 feet wide than the rough (accent on "rough") figure for the length of the side wall of the cabin measured my way would be 14 feet. Can somebody point an error in my methode or calculations?
Well, if the door was 2 feet wide than the rough (accent on "rough") figure for the length of the side wall of the cabin measured my way would be 14 feet. Can somebody point an error in my methode or calculations?
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken
-
cerberusjf
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
DariusP wrote:Ok John, first you will have to explain to me once again ( SLOWLY) why you are happy to accept that Admiral's Cabin sits conveniently between frames 78 and 74 and than go through complicated ( and, by your own admission, not very accurate) series of calculations to get its length? Since frames in Borodino were 4 feet apart, so the length of the cabin would be 16 feet or 4.9 meters. Now, did I miss something?
Okay, I hope I can. When I looked at the photo Andrew posted, it occurred to me that the forward window looked too far back on the cabin to match the plans for the lower deck house.
This was assumed to contain only the admiral's cabin until now, although there was doubt about if there was more (remember the dotted lines we talked about?) . Also my assumption no 3 when I was trying to define the lower cabin there was some doubt
cerberusjf wrote:I assumed that.
1 the frames on the lower deck would be the same as the upper.
2 the frame visible at the top of the cabin was "78" as it appeared to be in the right spot.
3 that 5 to 6 of the frames beyond frame "78" were part of the cabin. I thought you could see the white ends as they went through the black wall of the cabin. I thought it that it was possible there were more, but there was not enough light in the photo to see.
http://s229.photobucket.com/albums/ee27 ... nt=305.jpg
It also didn't fit the photo on the 6 "ringed" frames if the deck house ended at the 6th frame, even if there was room next to the forward window for a door .
So I tried to find out how long the deck house was.
To get the deckhouse length on the plans, I first had to find out the length on the photo, so I measured it =Bp
I could not relate this to a length on the plans, so I had to find something that I could use as a reference. Basically I needed a calibration measurement.
I thought a good way was to pick something identifiable that was near the middle. I thought the best thing to pick was the forward edge of the forward window. It was on the plans as well, so I could get a calibration. So I measured it on the photo =Ap.
I measured everything on the horizontal because that way they were measured exactly at the same angle.
I then measured the distance from the back of the deckhouse to the forward edge of the window on the plans =A
So we need to find the length og the deck house on the plans = B
We know the ratio of A:B is the same as Ap:Bp
so A/B=Ap/Bp
or if we invert both sides
B/A= Bp/Ap
so if we multiply both sides with A
B= A*(Bp/Ap)
or, because I already had Ap/Bp I did
B= A/(Ap/Bp)
I am not sure if this answers your question.
Maybe I should clarify what I mean by the "admirals cabin". I define it as the space that makes the admiral cabin and the walls that define it. this is enclosed between frame 78 and 74, drawn in red.
I am not including the walls around the stairwell in this (should they exist) drawn in green. My only basis for this confidence is the plans.
I think you are calling (what I call) the whole lower deckhouse the "admirals cabin", is that where the confusion lies?
I think the problem is that you have included part of the door in your door width.DariusP wrote:Well, if the door was 2 feet wide than the rough (accent on "rough") figure for the length of the side wall of the cabin measured my way would be 14 feet. Can somebody point an error in my methode or calculations?
I have outlined the foor in orange, the door space in blue. I cut and pasted the door width and I get 9 door widths = 18ft !! This is, of course very rough as well, I tried it two more times using different possible points for the limits of the door and and got 9.5 and 10 door widths. It is difficult to see exactly where the door width starts and ends.
CORRECTION The following part is incorrect-please ignore or to see why, see my later posts
(When I first read your post I was convinced you were right, or there may be some other explanation, like the windows were a different size from the plans or were in a diffferent place. So I checked and I am afraid to say that yes, one is in a different place. The Foremost one is actually farther FORWARD, between 4th and 5th "frame"!! This means that the cabin is actually longer than I had thought. It just gets more and more complicated!!!)
Last edited by cerberusjf on Wed Feb 13, 2008 5:44 am, edited 7 times in total.
-
cerberusjf
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
CORRECTION The following part is incorrect-please ignore or to see why, see my later posts
i revised the plans slightly to show the new position of the window.
This makes A bigger, so makes B bigger, pretty much up to frame 72. This does not make sense at all.. what is going on???
i revised the plans slightly to show the new position of the window.
This makes A bigger, so makes B bigger, pretty much up to frame 72. This does not make sense at all.. what is going on???
Last edited by cerberusjf on Tue Feb 12, 2008 3:52 pm, edited 2 times in total.
-
DariusP
- Posts: 941
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 2:08 pm
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
John, he more I look at your explanations the more I become convinced that you are onto something! As you have pointed out I have indeed included a part of the door in my calculations. When I corrected this I got whole wall length as 17.8 feet which is close enough to your result.
But just to clarify it completly: so the Admiral's Cabin (red outhine) will still be 14 feet long but if we add "staircase space" (green) than (according to your calculation and the dotted line in drawings) the whole structure will be about 18 feet long. Is that correct?
One furter clarification: when you say "To get the cabin length on the plans, I first had to find out the length on the photo" I wonder why? As I have said before: Admiral's Cabin (red) sits between frames 78 and 74. Since frames are 4 feet apart you have your lenght straight away!
As I see it "staircase space" has to be walled and included in the whole stucture. I can be no other explanation for the extra length of the wall!
And last but not least: when I talk about "frames" I mean hull frames. What you call "lower and upper deck frames" are deck stiffeners and if they align with hull frames it is only coincidental
But just to clarify it completly: so the Admiral's Cabin (red outhine) will still be 14 feet long but if we add "staircase space" (green) than (according to your calculation and the dotted line in drawings) the whole structure will be about 18 feet long. Is that correct?
One furter clarification: when you say "To get the cabin length on the plans, I first had to find out the length on the photo" I wonder why? As I have said before: Admiral's Cabin (red) sits between frames 78 and 74. Since frames are 4 feet apart you have your lenght straight away!
As I see it "staircase space" has to be walled and included in the whole stucture. I can be no other explanation for the extra length of the wall!
And last but not least: when I talk about "frames" I mean hull frames. What you call "lower and upper deck frames" are deck stiffeners and if they align with hull frames it is only coincidental
"On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron." H. L. Mencken
-
cerberusjf
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
Yes, that's rightDariusP wrote:John, he more I look at your explanations the more I become convinced that you are onto something! As you have pointed out I have indeed included a part of the door in my calculations. When I corrected this I got whole wall length as 17.8 feet which is close enough to your result.
But just to clarify it completly: so the Admiral's Cabin (red outhine) will still be 14 feet long but if we add "staircase space" (green) than (according to your calculation and the dotted line in drawings) the whole structure will be about 18 feet long. Is that correct?
I am not differentiating between the Admiral's cabin and stairwell to be pedantic, it is in case we have to revisit the bulkhead at or around frame 74
To me that does not make sense. It would mean a door opening up into a small area against the mast. Also the base of the mast was used for pulleys and so on so I would have expected it to be free of surrounding superstructure.
Sorry, here I meant deck house ie the red and green part together. I'll change it..DariusP wrote: One furter clarification: when you say "To get the cabin length on the plans, I first had to find out the length on the photo" I wonder why? As I have said before: Admiral's Cabin (red) sits between frames 78 and 74. Since frames are 4 feet apart you have your lenght straight away!
I think so too, according to the plan..DariusP wrote: As I see it "staircase space" has to be walled and included in the whole stucture. I can be no other explanation for the extra length of the wall!
I am not sure what you mean here, do you mean when I say, something like "the frame aft of frame 72"? If that's so, I take your pointDariusP wrote: And last but not least: when I talk about "frames" I mean hull frames. What you call "lower and upper deck frames" are deck stiffeners and if they align with hull frames it is only coincidental
Last edited by cerberusjf on Tue Feb 12, 2008 6:09 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
cerberusjf
Re: Calling all Borodino-class fans
I think you could well be right, but the deckhouse length will have to be revised. This is because the forward window appears to be further forward than I thought, it implies that the whole deckhouse is longer than I thought.
This is getting quite complex.

